AA, SMART Recovery and Stoicism: an honest comparison
There is no single right way to stop drinking. AA, SMART Recovery and Stoic philosophy are three different kinds of help - a fellowship, a skills programme and a philosophy of life. Here is what each one actually offers, what the evidence says, and how they fit together.
Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone
If you only do one thing
Find one meeting - AA or SMART, in person or online - that you could attend this week, and write down the day and time.
The short version
- AA is a free, worldwide fellowship built around the 12 Steps, regular meetings and sponsorship. A 2020 Cochrane review found that AA and programmes that encourage AA attendance usually produced higher rates of continuous abstinence than other established treatments.
- SMART Recovery is a free, secular programme of meetings and tools based on cognitive behavioural therapy, organised around four points - motivation, urges, thoughts and feelings, and a balanced life.
- Stoicism is not a programme or a treatment. It is a philosophy of life that offers ways of thinking and daily practices, and it works alongside either group.
- Many people use more than one. The best choice is often the one you will actually keep going to.
- None of these replaces medical advice if you are drinking heavily every day.
Three different kinds of help
It is easy to talk about AA, SMART Recovery and Stoicism as if they were three competing products. They are not really the same kind of thing.
- Alcoholics Anonymous is a fellowship: a community of people who meet to stay sober together, using a shared programme, the 12 Steps.
- SMART Recovery is a skills-based mutual-help programme: meetings and tools drawn from cognitive behavioural therapy, aimed at helping people manage their own recovery.
- Stoicism is a philosophy of life: a way of thinking about what is in your control, what matters, and how to live well. It comes with practices but no meetings, membership or programme.
That difference matters, because it means you are not forced to choose. Many people combine a group with a philosophy, or use one group for some things and another for others. This page sets out what each offers so you can decide what you need.
Alcoholics Anonymous
What it is
AA began in the United States in 1935 and now has meetings in most countries. It describes itself as “a fellowship of people who come together to solve their drinking problem”. Membership is free and open to anyone who wants to do something about their drinking. AA says it is not allied with any religious denomination, and its only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.
How it works
- Meetings, in person or online, where members share their experience. Many towns have several meetings a day.
- The 12 Steps, a sequence that moves from admitting the problem, through a moral inventory and making amends, to helping others. (This site maps each step to a Stoic idea in the 12 Steps and Stoicism.)
- Sponsorship - a more experienced member who guides a newcomer through the steps and is available when things are hard.
- Abstinence - AA’s goal is to stop drinking completely, one day at a time.
What the evidence says
AA has been studied far more than any other mutual-help group. In 2020, the Cochrane Collaboration - which produces some of the most rigorous evidence reviews in medicine - published a major review of AA and Twelve-Step Facilitation (clinical programmes designed to encourage AA participation). Its key findings:
- Manualised AA/TSF interventions usually produced higher rates of continuous abstinence than the other established treatments studied, such as CBT.
- AA/TSF probably performed as well as other treatments for reducing drinking intensity, alcohol-related consequences and addiction severity.
- Most of the economic studies found substantial healthcare cost savings.
The review’s authors rated their certainty in the evidence from very low to high depending on the outcome, so it is not the last word. But it is strong evidence that AA helps many people.
Who it tends to suit
AA tends to suit people who want regular contact with others in recovery, a clear structure, and the support of someone who has been through it. The availability of meetings - including late at night and at weekends - is a real strength.
Common objections
- The spiritual language. The steps refer to God and a “Higher Power”. Many members interpret this loosely - as the group, the programme, or principles - and there are secular and agnostic AA meetings in many areas. Others never feel comfortable with it.
- “Powerlessness”. Some people find Step 1’s admission of powerlessness unhelpful. Others find it a relief. This site’s Step 1 page offers a Stoic reading: you are powerless over the urge arriving, but not over what you do next.
- Labels. Introducing yourself as an alcoholic suits some people and not others. It is a custom, not a requirement.
SMART Recovery
What it is
SMART stands for Self-Management and Recovery Training. It began in the United States in the 1990s and now runs meetings in many countries, including across the UK. SMART Recovery UK describes itself as “an evidence-based recovery method grounded in Cognitive Behavioural Therapy”. Meetings are free and run by trained facilitators.
How it works
SMART is organised around a four-point programme:
- Build and maintain motivation - finding your reasons for change and keeping them in view.
- Cope with urges and cravings - practical techniques for getting through them.
- Manage thoughts, feelings and behaviours - largely CBT-based tools for working with unhelpful thinking.
- Live a balanced life - building a life that does not need the addictive behaviour.
Meetings are discussion-based and focus on tools and problem-solving rather than personal stories alone. SMART does not use labels such as “alcoholic”, does not involve a Higher Power, and does not require any particular goal, though many participants aim for abstinence.
What the evidence says
SMART’s methods are drawn from approaches with a good evidence base, especially CBT and motivational interviewing. In England, NICE recommends cognitive behavioural therapies among the psychological interventions for harmful drinking and mild dependence. Research on SMART meetings themselves is much more limited than research on AA. It would be fair to say SMART uses evidence-based techniques, but the evidence on SMART as a group programme is still developing.
Who it tends to suit
SMART tends to suit people who want a secular, practical, skills-focused approach and who are put off by the spiritual language or labels in AA. People who like structured tools and worksheets often feel at home there.
Common objections
- Fewer meetings. In many places there are far fewer SMART meetings than AA meetings, though online meetings help.
- Less personal support. SMART does not have a formal sponsorship system, so some people miss the one-to-one relationship AA offers.
Stoicism
What it is
Stoicism is a school of philosophy founded in Athens around 300 BC and developed in Rome by Seneca, Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius. It is not a recovery programme, has no meetings or members, and is not a treatment. It is a way of thinking about life - what is in your control, what really matters, how to respond to difficulty - and a set of daily practices for living that way.
How people use it in recovery
- Ways of thinking - especially the dichotomy of control (what is up to you and what is not), testing impressions (examining the thought “I need a drink” before acting on it), and seeing the craving plainly.
- Daily practices - morning preparation, the evening review, a daily reading.
- Values - the four Stoic virtues of wisdom, courage, justice and self-control give recovery something to aim at beyond not drinking.
- Reading - the Stoic writers are honest companions on difficult days.
What the evidence says
There is no trial evidence for Stoicism as a treatment for alcohol problems, and it would be wrong to claim otherwise. Its central ideas overlap heavily with CBT, which does have evidence behind it (see Stoicism and CBT), and with relapse prevention techniques. But Stoicism itself has not been tested in this way.
Who it tends to suit
People who think analytically, who want a framework rather than a programme, or who find religious language difficult often find Stoicism appealing. It also suits people who already attend a group and want a philosophy to deepen their practice. Many in AA find Stoic ideas fit the steps closely; many in SMART find they fit the tools.
Limits
- No community. On its own, Stoicism offers no meetings, no sponsor and no one to call. For most people in early recovery, that contact with others matters a great deal. Marcus Aurelius himself wrote, “Be not ashamed to be helped.”
- Not a treatment. It cannot manage withdrawal, assess risk, or replace professional care.
- Easy to misread. “Stoic” in everyday English means keeping a stiff upper lip. That is not what the Stoics taught, and toughing it out alone is a poor recovery plan.
Side by side
| AA | SMART Recovery | Stoicism | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Fellowship with a 12-step programme | Skills-based mutual-help programme | Philosophy of life |
| Cost | Free | Free meetings; optional paid handbook | Free (the texts are public domain) |
| Meetings | Very widely available, in person and online | Fewer, in person and online | None |
| One-to-one support | Sponsorship | No formal sponsor | None built in |
| Spiritual language | Yes (Higher Power, interpreted variously) | No | Optional - works for religious and secular people |
| Goal | Abstinence | Your choice; many aim for abstinence | Freedom from compulsion |
| Evidence | Strongest of the three (Cochrane 2020) | Based on evidence-based methods; limited direct research | No direct trials; overlaps with CBT |
| Labels | “Alcoholic” customary | No labels | No labels |
How people combine them
In practice, many people do not choose just one.
- AA plus Stoicism. The 12 Steps and Stoic ideas fit together surprisingly well - powerlessness and the dichotomy of control, the moral inventory and the evening review, carrying the message and the Stoic idea that we are made to help one another. This site’s 12 Steps pages explore each step.
- SMART plus Stoicism. SMART’s CBT-based tools share roots with the Stoics. The cost-benefit analysis and Epictetus’s “picture both times” exercise are close cousins.
- A group plus therapy. Many people use a mutual-help group alongside one-to-one therapy or a structured treatment programme.
- Trying several. It is common to try different meetings or groups before finding one that fits. A bad first meeting does not mean the whole approach is wrong for you.
How to choose
A few honest questions may help:
- Do you want regular contact with other people in recovery? If so, start with a group - AA, SMART, or both.
- Does spiritual language help or hinder you? If it gets in the way, try SMART or a secular AA meeting. If it helps, traditional AA may suit you well.
- Do you want practical tools or shared experience? SMART leans towards tools, AA towards shared experience and step work. Both have some of each.
- Do you want a philosophy to live by? Stoicism offers that, whichever group you choose.
- What will you actually go to? The best support is the one you keep using. If one approach is easier to attend, start there.
And whatever you choose, if you are drinking heavily every day, speak to a doctor before stopping. The NHS alcohol support page lists services in the UK, and this site’s support page has helplines for other countries.
One thing for tonight
Ask yourself honestly what you need most right now - people, practical tools, or a philosophy - and start there.
Questions
Is AA or SMART Recovery more effective?
There is much more research on AA than on SMART Recovery. The 2020 Cochrane review found that AA and clinically delivered programmes that encourage AA attendance usually produced higher rates of continuous abstinence than other established treatments, and performed about as well on other measures. Smaller studies of SMART Recovery suggest it can help too, but the evidence base is less developed. In practice, the right group is the one you will attend and engage with.
Do I have to believe in God to go to AA?
No. AA describes itself as not allied with any religious denomination, and many members interpret the “Higher Power” in the 12 Steps in non-religious ways - the group, the programme, or principles such as honesty. Some people still find the language too spiritual, and that is one reason SMART Recovery and secular AA meetings exist.
Can I use Stoicism instead of AA or SMART Recovery?
Stoicism is a philosophy, not a recovery programme, and it has not been tested as a treatment. On its own it lacks the regular contact with other people in recovery that groups provide, which many people find essential. It works best alongside a group, therapy or medical support rather than instead of them.
Can I go to both AA and SMART Recovery?
Yes. Some people attend both, using AA for fellowship and sponsorship and SMART for practical tools. Both welcome people who use other forms of support.
What about professional treatment?
Groups and philosophy are not a substitute for medical care when it is needed. In England, NICE recommends psychological therapies such as CBT for harmful drinking and mild dependence, and specialist services for more severe dependence. Your GP is a good place to start. If you drink heavily every day, get medical advice before stopping.
Sources and further reading
- Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder Kelly, Humphreys and Ferri, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)The major review of the evidence on AA and 12-step facilitation.
- What is A.A.? Alcoholics AnonymousA free fellowship open to anyone who wants to do something about their drinking, not allied with any religious denomination.
- Alcoholics Anonymous Great Britain AA
- The SMART Recovery 4-point program SMART Recovery USABuild and maintain motivation; cope with urges and cravings; manage thoughts, feelings and behaviours; live a balanced life. Meetings are free.
- SMART Recovery UK SMART Recovery
- Alcohol-use disorders (CG115): recommendations NICERecommends offering a psychological intervention, such as cognitive behavioural therapy, for harmful drinking and mild alcohol dependence.
- Alcohol support NHSWhere to get help in the UK, including Drinkline (0300 123 1110), AA, SMART Recovery and Al-Anon.
- Relapse prevention: an overview of Marlatt’s cognitive-behavioral model Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, Alcohol Research & Health (1999)High-risk situations, coping skills, urge management and the “abstinence violation effect” after a lapse.
- Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.