The Stoics, in their own words

What the Stoics actually said about wine and drunkenness

The Stoics were not teetotallers, and anyone who tells you they were has not read Seneca. But they thought harder about drinking than almost anyone in the ancient world - and their reasoning, read honestly, points somewhere useful for anyone whose drinking has become a habit.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Describe the drink you want as plainly as Marcus described Falernian - a liquid that will change how you feel for an hour, then take your sleep. Then decide.

The short version

  • Seneca devoted a whole letter (Letter 83) to drunkenness. He called it “a condition of insanity purposely assumed” and said it does not create vices but exposes them.
  • He also wrote, in On Tranquillity of Mind, that we should occasionally drink freely - but “we ought not to do it often, for fear the mind should contract evil habits”. His own condition is the one that rules it out for anyone whose drinking is already a habit.
  • Marcus Aurelius admired the ability to both abstain and enjoy - and noted that many people are “too weak to abstain from, and cannot enjoy without excess”. For them, abstaining is the strong choice.
  • Epictetus treated any pleasure as an impression to be tested before you act, and said habits grow on the actions that feed them and weaken when starved.
  • Musonius Rufus, Epictetus’s teacher, held that mastering the appetite for food and drink is the foundation of self-control.

Wine in the Stoic world

It helps to start with what the Stoics were not. They were not a temperance movement, and they did not live in a world where abstaining was normal. Wine was the everyday drink of the Roman world: served at meals, poured at religious rites, shared at the dinner parties where much of Roman social and political life took place. It was usually mixed with water, and drinking it neat was considered a mark of excess.

Most Stoics drank. What interested them was not whether wine was allowed but who was in charge: the person or the appetite. Stoicism held that the only true good is a well-ordered mind, and that external things - money, reputation, comfort, pleasure - are neither good nor bad in themselves. What matters is how you use them, and whether you can do without them.

That is why their writing on wine is more useful to someone in recovery than a simple rule would be. They were not interested in whether drinking is permitted. They were interested in whether you are free - which is exactly the question a person trying to stop is wrestling with.

Seneca’s Letter 83: a whole letter on drunkenness

Seneca’s Moral Letters to Lucilius were written in the last years of his life, to a friend trying to live more wisely. Letter 83 begins with Seneca’s daily routine and ends up as one of the most vivid pieces on drunkenness ever written.

First, he mocks a bad argument

The founder of Stoicism, Zeno, had tried to prove that a good man will not get drunk with a piece of formal logic. Seneca quotes it:

“No one entrusts a secret to a drunken man; but one will entrust a secret to a good man; therefore, the good man will not get drunk.”

Then he takes it apart with a parody: “No one entrusts a secret to a man when he is asleep; but one entrusts a secret to a good man; therefore, the good man does not go to sleep.” He goes on to list Roman officials who drank heavily and kept secrets perfectly well - including Lucius Piso, who “was drunk from the very time of his appointment” as city prefect, and still did the job.

This is worth noticing. Seneca had no time for weak arguments against drinking, even from the founder of his own school. Clever proofs did not impress him. The anti-drinking case had to stand on what drinking actually does.

Then he makes the real case

Here is how he thought the argument should be made instead:

“Show how base it is to pour down more liquor than one can carry, and not to know the capacity of one’s own stomach; show how often the drunkard does things which make him blush when he is sober; state that drunkenness is nothing but a condition of insanity purposely assumed.”

A condition of insanity purposely assumed. It is a remarkable phrase for a Roman aristocrat writing two thousand years ago, and it describes the experience of many people who drink too much: a temporary madness that you choose, knowing roughly what it will cost. He pushes the point: “Prolong the drunkard’s condition to several days; will you have any doubt about his madness? Even as it is, the madness is no less; it merely lasts a shorter time.”

Drink reveals rather than creates

Seneca’s most psychologically sharp observation is about what alcohol does to character:

“Drunkenness does not create vice, it merely brings it into view.”

He explains that many people avoid bad actions out of shame rather than goodness, and wine removes the shame. The angry man grows violent, the arrogant man more arrogant, the cruel man crueller. “Every vice is given free play and comes to the front.”

Anyone who has watched their own behaviour change after a few drinks will recognise this. It cuts both ways. It is uncomfortable, because it suggests the things we did while drinking were ours, not the drink’s. It is also hopeful: it means the work of recovery is not only about the bottle. It is about the anger, fear or loneliness that the bottle kept letting out.

The body, and the morning after

Seneca does not skip the physical side. He describes the slurred words, the unsteady glance, the faltering step, “the very ceiling moves about as if a cyclone were whirling the whole house”, and the stomach in torment. Then the worst part, he says, is not the drunkenness but what it turns into while you sleep.

His examples are from history. Alexander the Great stabbed his loyal friend Clitus at a banquet and then wished to die. Mark Antony, “a great man, a man of distinguished ability”, was ruined, Seneca says, by drink and his love of Cleopatra. “Cruelty usually follows wine-bibbing,” he writes, and then makes a point about habit that sounds strikingly modern:

“For when people are often beside themselves, the habit of madness lasts on, and the vices which liquor generated retain their power even when the liquor is gone.”

That is a fair description of what many people find in early sobriety. The drink is gone, but the patterns it trained - the short temper, the escape reflex, the 6pm craving - take time to fade.

“Vanquished by the cask”

Seneca also takes aim at the culture of heavy drinking as a competition - the person who can drink everyone under the table:

“When you have won the prize, and the other banqueters, sprawling asleep or vomiting, have declined your challenge to still other toasts; when you are the last survivor of the revels… you are vanquished by the cask.”

If you have ever been proud of how much you could drink, it is worth sitting with that line. The prize for winning is losing.

And the letter has a quieter detail that is easy to miss. Discussing the plot against Julius Caesar, Seneca notes that “Cassius throughout his life drank water”. In a culture where wine was everywhere, Seneca records a man who simply did not drink - and he mentions it without any suggestion that it was strange.

The awkward passage: Seneca says drink, sometimes

An honest account has to include this. In his essay On Tranquillity of Mind, Seneca recommends rest, walks, travel and good company to restore a tired mind, and then says this:

”…sometimes we gain strength by driving in a carriage, by travel, by change of air, or by social meals and a more generous allowance of wine: at times we ought to drink even to intoxication, not so as to drown, but merely to dip ourselves in wine: for wine washes away troubles and dislodges them from the depths of the mind, and acts as a remedy to sorrow as it does to some diseases.”

That is not what a recovery website would like Seneca to have said. But look at what comes next:

“Yet moderation is wholesome both in freedom and in wine… however, we ought not to do it often, for fear the mind should contract evil habits.”

So even Seneca’s permission comes with a condition, and the condition is about habit. He was writing for a friend who drank occasionally and could stop. His advice assumes that the occasional drink stays occasional, and he warns explicitly against letting it become regular “for fear the mind should contract evil habits”.

If your drinking has already become a habit - if the occasional has become nightly, if the remedy for sorrow has become a source of it - then you are exactly the person Seneca’s warning was written for. His own reasoning rules it out. The passage is not a loophole. It is a description of a freedom you may not currently have, and the warning describes how it is lost.

There is a broader point here about reading the Stoics. They were not writing rules for everyone. They were trying to describe how a free mind behaves. For some people, a free mind can have a glass of wine at a festival and think nothing more of it. For others, the free choice is not to drink at all, because they have learned what one drink leads to. The Stoics would have recognised both as wisdom. What they would not have recognised as wisdom is a person telling themselves they are free while their drinking tells a different story.

Marcus Aurelius: grape juice, and the strength to abstain

Seeing Falernian as grape juice

Falernian was the most celebrated wine in Rome - the Château Lafite of its day. Marcus Aurelius used it as an example of how to see things clearly:

“When we have meat before us and such eatables, we receive the impression that this is the dead body of a fish, and this the dead body of a bird or of a pig; and again, that this Falernian is only a little grape-juice, and this purple robe some sheep’s wool dyed with the blood of a shell-fish.”

He was not saying wine is disgusting. He was practising a technique: stripping a thing of its glamour so you can see what it really is. “Just in the same way ought we to act all through life,” he continues, “and where there are things which appear most worthy of our approbation, we ought to lay them bare and look at their worthlessness and take away all the words by which they are exalted.”

Alcohol is surrounded by more glamour than almost anything else we consume - advertising, ritual, celebration, sophistication, reward. Marcus’s exercise works as well now as it did then. Describe the drink you want in the plainest terms possible, then describe what it will do over the next twelve hours. Much of the craving turns out to have been for the story, not the liquid. The Insight Tool uses this as one of its angles.

Those who cannot enjoy without excess

In the first book of the Meditations, Marcus lists what he learned from the people who shaped him. Writing about his adoptive father, the emperor Antoninus Pius, he applies a line remembered about Socrates:

”…he was able both to abstain from, and to enjoy, those things which many are too weak to abstain from, and cannot enjoy without excess.”

This is the Stoic ideal: to be able to take a pleasure or leave it. But notice the honesty in the second half. Marcus knows that “many” cannot enjoy certain pleasures without excess. He does not pretend everyone can moderate.

For someone in recovery, this line draws a clear map. If you can genuinely take alcohol or leave it, the Stoics have no quarrel with you. If you cannot enjoy it without excess, then the strength Marcus admired is available to you in only one form: the ability to abstain. That is not a lesser version of the ideal. It is the ideal, applied honestly to your situation.

Epictetus: test the impression, starve the habit

Epictetus, who had been born a slave and became the most influential Stoic teacher of his time, wrote little about wine directly. But his method is the most practical tool the Stoics left for anyone resisting a craving.

Every pleasure is an impression

In the Enchiridion he writes:

“If you are dazzled by the semblance of any promised pleasure, guard yourself against being bewildered by it; but let the affair wait your leisure, and procure yourself some delay. Then bring to your mind both points of time - that in which you shall enjoy the pleasure, and that in which you will repent and reproach yourself, after you have enjoyed it - and set before you, in opposition to these, how you will rejoice and applaud yourself if you abstain.”

There are three moves in that passage, and each is a recognisable recovery technique:

  1. Delay. Do not decide in the moment of the craving. Let it wait. This is the idea behind the Urge Timer.
  2. Picture both times. Hold the moment of pleasure next to the moment after. Not to punish yourself, but to see accurately.
  3. Imagine abstaining. Picture how you will feel if you do not act. Epictetus thought that satisfaction was itself a real pleasure - and anyone who has woken up clear-headed after a hard evening knows he was right.

The body is not the main event

Epictetus also had a blunt view of how much attention bodily appetites deserve:

“It is a mark of want of intellect to spend much time in things relating to the body, as to be immoderate in exercises, in eating and drinking, and in the discharge of other animal functions. These things should be done incidentally and our main strength be applied to our reason.”

Drinking at its worst becomes a full-time occupation: planning it, doing it, recovering from it, hiding it, worrying about it. Epictetus’s point is that appetite deserves a small corner of life, not the centre.

Habits grow on what feeds them

Finally, Epictetus’s Discourses contain what may be the most useful single passage for anyone counting sober days. Writing about anger, he says:

“Every habit and faculty is maintained and increased by the corresponding actions… If then you wish not to be of an angry temper, do not feed the habit: throw nothing on it which will increase it: at first keep quiet, and count the days on which you have not been angry.”

He describes the progress: angry every day, then every second day, then every third. “But if you have intermitted thirty days, make a sacrifice to God. For the habit at first begins to be weakened, and then is completely destroyed.”

Replace anger with drinking and you have a very old version of counting days. The logic is the same: every evening the habit goes unfed, it weakens a little. You are not trying to win once. You are starving something over time.

Musonius Rufus: self-control starts at the table

Musonius Rufus is the least known of the four great Roman Stoics, partly because his teachings survive only in notes taken by his students. He was Epictetus’s teacher, and he was unusually concerned with daily habits: what people ate, how they slept, how they dressed.

According to the Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Musonius held that mastering one’s appetites for food and drink is the basis of self-control, which he counted among the most important virtues. He also believed in deliberately training the body and mind through small hardships - getting used to thirst, hunger and simple living - so that pleasures lose their power to command us.

That idea maps neatly onto recovery. The appetite for alcohol is not separate from the rest of life. Learning to sit with an urge without acting on it is the same muscle as any other kind of self-control, and it gets stronger with use.

What this means if you are trying to stop

Read together, the Stoics give a consistent picture. It is not “alcohol is evil”. It is something more useful:

1. The question is freedom, not permission. The Stoics never asked whether drinking was allowed. They asked whether you govern it or it governs you. If you are reading this because you are worried about your drinking, you probably already know the answer for yourself.

2. Moderation is a privilege of those who have it. Seneca allowed occasional festive drinking for people who drank occasionally, and warned against making it habitual. Marcus admired people who could take it or leave it, and admitted that many cannot. Neither offers any support to the idea that someone with a drinking habit should keep trying to moderate.

3. Drink exposes what is underneath. Seneca’s point that drunkenness reveals rather than creates vice means recovery is about more than stopping. It is about dealing with the anger, fear, shame or loneliness that drinking kept letting out - and kept us from addressing.

4. Habits are starved, not defeated. Epictetus’s counted days are a reminder that progress is gradual. The habit weakens each time it goes unfed, and the patterns drink trained can take time to fade.

5. See the thing as it is. Marcus’s grape juice exercise, Epictetus’s test of the impression and Seneca’s catalogue of the morning after all aim at the same thing: seeing past the glamour of the drink to the reality of what it does.

None of the Stoics was a doctor, and none of this replaces medical help. If you drink heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous, and the NHS advises getting medical help first. But for the thinking part of recovery - the arguments in your head at 6pm, the bargaining, the “just one” - the Stoics are as good a companion as you will find.

Reading the sources yourself

All of the passages on this page come from public-domain translations, free to read online:

  • Seneca, Letter 83 (“On Drunkenness”), in Richard Mott Gummere’s translation of the Moral Letters to Lucilius, on Wikisource.
  • Seneca, On Tranquillity of Mind, chapter 17, in Aubrey Stewart’s translation of the Minor Dialogues.
  • Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 1.16 and 6.13, in George Long’s translation.
  • Epictetus, Enchiridion 34 and 41*, in Thomas Wentworth Higginson’s translation, and Discourses 2.18*, in George Long’s.

Every quotation has been checked against those texts. The full list of sources is below.

One thing for tonight

Read Epictetus’s three steps - delay, picture both times, imagine abstaining - and use them on the next urge, in that order.

Questions

Were the Stoics against drinking alcohol?

Not as a rule. Most Stoics drank wine, which was part of ordinary Roman life, and Seneca even recommended occasional festive drinking. What they opposed was drunkenness and being ruled by any appetite. Their key test was freedom - whether you govern the pleasure or it governs you.

Did Seneca drink wine?

Seneca wrote about wine as something normal and enjoyable, and in On Tranquillity of Mind he recommended occasionally drinking more generously to relax the mind. In Letter 83 he condemned drunkenness in the strongest terms. He also praised Gaius Cassius, who “throughout his life drank water”.

Is giving up alcohol a Stoic thing to do?

For someone whose drinking has become a habit, yes. The Stoic ideal was to be free of compulsion. Marcus Aurelius admired people who could “both abstain from, and enjoy” pleasures, and noted that many people cannot enjoy them without excess. If you are one of them, abstaining is how you get your freedom back. Seneca himself warned against drinking often “for fear the mind should contract evil habits”.

What did Marcus Aurelius say about wine?

In Meditations 6.13 he trained himself to see the famous Falernian wine as “only a little grape-juice” - stripping away its glamour so he could judge it plainly. In Meditations 1.16 he praised the ability to abstain from pleasures that many cannot enjoy without excess.

What does “insanity purposely assumed” mean?

It is Seneca’s description of drunkenness in Letter 83. His point was that a drunk person is temporarily mad - and chose to be. “Prolong the drunkard’s condition to several days,” he wrote, “will you have any doubt about his madness?”

Sources and further reading

  1. Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource
  2. Seneca’s Minor Dialogues (including On Anger and On the Shortness of Life), translated by Aubrey Stewart Project Gutenberg eBook 64576
  3. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  4. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  5. A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
  6. Musonius Rufus Internet Encyclopedia of PhilosophyMusonius taught that mastering the appetites for food and drink is the foundation of self-control.
  7. Seneca, Lucius Annaeus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  8. Seneca Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  9. Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  10. Alcohol-use disorder NHSSigns of dependence, withdrawal symptoms, and why stopping suddenly can be dangerous if you are dependent.

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.