Choosing your support

Quitting drinking without AA

Alcoholics Anonymous has helped millions of people, and the evidence for it is strong. It is also not for everyone. If AA does not suit you, there are other good approaches - and you can build a structured, supported recovery without it.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Choose one source of support you will try this week - a SMART Recovery meeting, a GP appointment, a call to an alcohol helpline - and write down when.

The short version

  • AA has the strongest research base of any mutual-help group - a 2020 Cochrane review found AA and programmes encouraging it often produced higher rates of continuous abstinence. It is worth an honest try if you have not given it one.
  • If AA does not suit you, alternatives include SMART Recovery, professional help through your GP or a local alcohol service, talking therapies such as CBT, and online communities.
  • What matters most is not which approach you choose but that you have structure, support and a plan.
  • Stoic philosophy can provide a framework of ideas and daily practices, but it is not a programme or a treatment, and it works best alongside support from other people.
  • If you drink heavily every day, speak to your GP before stopping.

Some people walk into an AA meeting and feel instantly at home. Others find the spiritual language, the labels or the format a barrier they cannot get past. If you are in the second group, it is easy to conclude that recovery is not for you.

It is. AA is one approach, and a good one, but it is not the only one. This page sets out the alternatives honestly - including why AA might still be worth a second look - and how to build a recovery with structure and support either way.

Pause here for a moment. Breathe in as the circle grows and out as it shrinks. Three slow breaths is enough. The rest of the page will wait.

First, a fair word about AA

It would be wrong to write a page about quitting without AA without being honest about the evidence. In 2020, the Cochrane Collaboration published a major review of AA and Twelve-Step Facilitation (clinical programmes that encourage AA involvement). It found that these usually produced higher rates of continuous abstinence than other established treatments, and performed about as well on measures such as drinking intensity and alcohol-related problems.

So if you have not given AA a fair try - several meetings, different groups, perhaps a secular or agnostic meeting if there is one nearby - it may be worth doing. Many people who were put off by their first meeting found a group that suited them later.

But AA is not for everyone, and there is no reason to force it if it does not fit. Many people recover through other approaches.

Your options

SMART Recovery

SMART Recovery is the best-known secular alternative. SMART Recovery UK describes itself as “an evidence-based recovery method grounded in Cognitive Behavioural Therapy”. Meetings are free and run by trained facilitators, in person and online. It is organised around four points:

  1. build and maintain motivation
  2. cope with urges and cravings
  3. manage thoughts, feelings and behaviours
  4. live a balanced life

There is no Higher Power, no requirement to call yourself an alcoholic, and a strong focus on practical tools. Many people who find AA difficult feel at home in SMART. (AA, SMART Recovery and Stoicism compared.)

Your GP and local services

Your GP can assess your drinking, check your physical health, help you stop safely and refer you to local alcohol services. In the UK, those services are free and can offer structured support, counselling and help with withdrawal where needed. The NHS alcohol support page lists the options.

Talking therapies

In England, NICE guidance recommends psychological interventions - such as cognitive behavioural therapies - for harmful drinking and mild dependence. The NHS lists problems with alcohol among the conditions CBT can help with, and you can often refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies. (Stoicism and CBT.)

Online communities

There are many online recovery communities and apps. They vary a lot in quality, but some people find them a valuable source of daily connection, especially at times when no meeting is available.

Your own structured plan

Some people stop with a personal plan and the support of friends and family. This can work, especially for less severe problems - but it works best when the plan is specific and the support is real, not just “I’ll try harder this time”.

Stopping safely

Whatever approach you choose, if you drink heavily every day or get shaky, sweaty or very anxious without alcohol, speak to your GP before stopping. Stopping suddenly can be dangerous if you are dependent.

What every successful approach has in common

AA, SMART, therapy and personal plans look different on the surface. Underneath, the ones that work tend to share a few things:

  • Support from other people. Someone to call, a group to attend, a person who knows what you are doing.
  • Structure. Regular practices, routines and check-ins - not just good intentions.
  • A plan for hard moments. Knowing in advance what you will do when an urge or a high-risk situation arrives.
  • A reason. Something you are moving towards, not just away from.

If you build those four things, you have the heart of what makes recovery programmes work, whichever one you choose.

Where Stoicism fits

Stoic philosophy can provide some of that structure - especially the ideas and the daily practices. It cannot provide the people.

What it offers

  • A way of thinking about cravings. The dichotomy of control (the urge arriving is not yours to control; what you do next is), testing impressions (“I need a drink” is a thought to examine, not a command), and seeing a drink plainly. (The dichotomy of control.)
  • Daily practices. A morning preparation, an evening review, a daily reading. These provide the rhythm a programme gives.
  • Values to aim at. Wisdom, courage, justice and self-control - a positive picture of who you are becoming.
  • A secular framework. It works for people of any religion or none.

What it does not offer

  • Community. There are no Stoic meetings on a Tuesday night. You need people.
  • Treatment. Stoicism has not been tested as a treatment for alcohol problems.
  • Medical care. It cannot manage withdrawal or health risks.

The Stoics themselves would have insisted on getting help. Marcus Aurelius wrote:

“Be not ashamed to be helped; for it is your business to do your duty like a soldier in the assault on a town.”
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 7.7

He went on: if you cannot climb the wall alone but can with someone’s help, why refuse it? The point is to get over the wall.

And Seneca advised his friend to choose a person whose character he admired and live as though they were watching: “Choose therefore a Cato; or, if Cato seems too severe a model, choose some Laelius, a gentler spirit.” Recovery without AA still needs people - a mentor, a group, a friend whose steadiness you can borrow.

Remember

Leaving out AA does not mean leaving out support. Whatever approach you choose, make sure it includes people.

Build your own framework

A secular recovery plan
  1. Check it is safe to stop. Speak to your GP if you drink heavily every day.
  2. Choose your people. At least one group (SMART, secular AA, an online community) and one or two individuals you can contact any time.
  3. Choose your professional support. GP, local alcohol service, counsellor or CBT, as needed.
  4. Set your daily rhythm. Morning: name the day’s hard moment and how you will meet it. Evening: a three-question review. A short daily reading.
  5. Plan your hard moments. List your high-risk situations and what you will do in each. (Relapse prevention.)
  6. Know your tools. The Urge Timer, the Insight Tool and the HALT check-in all work offline.
  7. Review monthly. What is working? What needs more support?
One page, three parts

Tonight, write a single page with three headings: “Who will support me”, “What I will do every day”, and “What I will do in a hard moment”. Fill each section with specifics - names, times, actions. That page is your programme.

Wherever you end up

People sometimes move between approaches - trying SMART, then AA, then therapy, or combining them. That is fine. Recovery is not a test of loyalty to a method. It is about finding what helps you stay well, and using it.

If you would like help choosing, your GP or a local alcohol service can talk through options. In the UK, Drinkline is free and confidential on 0300 123 1110. In the US, the NIAAA Alcohol Treatment Navigator can help you find treatment.

One thing for tonight

Write a one-page plan with three parts - who will support me, what I will do each day, and what I will do when an urge or a hard moment arrives.

Questions

Can you quit drinking without AA?

Yes. Many people stop drinking through other approaches - SMART Recovery, professional treatment, therapy, other mutual-help groups or their own structured plan with support. What matters is having support and a plan that suits you.

What are the alternatives to AA?

Common alternatives include SMART Recovery (secular, CBT-based meetings), help from your GP or a local alcohol service, talking therapies such as CBT, and online recovery communities. In England, NICE recommends psychological interventions such as CBT for harmful drinking and mild dependence.

Is AA more effective than other approaches?

AA has the strongest evidence base. A 2020 Cochrane review found that AA and clinical programmes encouraging AA attendance usually produced higher rates of continuous abstinence than other established treatments, and performed about as well on other measures. That does not mean it is right for everyone, but it is worth considering seriously.

Is Stoicism enough on its own?

Stoicism is a philosophy, not a recovery programme, and it has not been tested as a treatment. Most people do better with support from others - a group, a counsellor, a doctor - alongside any philosophy or practices they find helpful.

Sources and further reading

  1. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder Kelly, Humphreys and Ferri, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)The major review of the evidence on AA and 12-step facilitation.
  2. SMART Recovery UK SMART Recovery
  3. The SMART Recovery 4-point program SMART Recovery USABuild and maintain motivation; cope with urges and cravings; manage thoughts, feelings and behaviours; live a balanced life. Meetings are free.
  4. Alcohol-use disorders (CG115): recommendations NICERecommends offering a psychological intervention, such as cognitive behavioural therapy, for harmful drinking and mild alcohol dependence.
  5. Alcohol support NHSWhere to get help in the UK, including Drinkline (0300 123 1110), AA, SMART Recovery and Al-Anon.
  6. Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) NHSLists problems with alcohol among the conditions CBT can help with; CBT is free on the NHS.
  7. Alcohol Treatment Navigator NIAAA
  8. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  9. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  10. Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.