The dichotomy of control and addiction
Epictetus began his handbook with one distinction - between what is in our power and what is not - and built everything else on it. For anyone fighting a craving, it may be the single most useful idea in all of Stoicism.
Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone
If you only do one thing
Draw a line down a page. Left side - everything about tonight you cannot control. Right side - what you can. Then do one thing from the right side, now.
The short version
- Epictetus divided everything into two groups - what is in our power (our judgements, choices and actions) and what is not (our body, other people, the past, outcomes, events).
- In recovery, the urge arriving is not in your control. What you do in the next ten minutes is.
- Much of the misery around drinking comes from fighting the wrong list - trying to control the urge, other people or the past, while neglecting the next action.
- The same idea sits behind the Serenity Prayer and Step 1 of the 12 Steps.
- Practised daily, it turns overwhelming situations into a short list of things you can actually do.
There is a moment in every craving when the whole world seems to shrink to one question: drink or don’t drink? And with it comes a feeling of helplessness - as though the urge itself were a force you have to defeat by sheer strength.
Epictetus, a former slave who became one of the most influential teachers in the ancient world, offered a different way of seeing that moment. It begins with one sentence.
Pause here for a moment. Breathe in as the circle grows and out as it shrinks. Three slow breaths is enough. The rest of the page will wait.
Epictetus’s distinction
The Enchiridion, the short handbook of Epictetus’s teaching, opens like this:
“There are things which are within our power, and there are things which are beyond our power.”
He goes on to list them. Within our power: our opinions, our desires and aversions, our choices - in short, our own actions. Beyond our power: our body, our property, our reputation, our position - whatever is not our own doing.
Then he makes the crucial point. The things within our power are free and unhindered. The things beyond our power are weak, dependent and belong to others. If you treat what belongs to others as your own, you will be frustrated and upset, and you will blame everyone. If you focus only on what is truly yours, no one can compel or harm you.
That may sound like an overstatement. But apply it to a craving, and it becomes very practical.
Applied to the urge
Here is a craving, sorted:
| Not in your control | In your control |
|---|---|
| The urge arriving | What you do in the next ten minutes |
| How strong it feels | Where you go - away from the alcohol |
| Your history with drinking | Whether you text someone |
| The time of day, the cue that set it off | Whether you set a timer and wait |
| Other people drinking around you | What you say when offered a drink |
| How you will feel tomorrow if you drink | Whether you drink tonight |
Look at the left column. Much of the panic in a craving comes from fighting things there - trying to make the urge go away, wishing you did not have this history, resenting the people drinking around you. None of that is in your power, and fighting it is exhausting.
Now look at the right column. It is short and specific. Everything on it is something you can actually do. The dichotomy of control does not ask you to defeat the urge. It asks you to choose your next action. That is a much smaller job.
You are not responsible for the urge arriving. You are responsible for what you do next - and what you do next is entirely yours.
Applied to the rest of recovery
The same distinction helps far beyond the moment of craving.
Other people. You cannot control whether your partner drinks, whether friends understand, or whether family members say the wrong thing. You can control your boundaries, your words and what support you seek for yourself. (When someone you love drinks.)
The past. What you did while drinking is done. You cannot change it. You can control whether you make amends, what you learn from it and how you live now. (Amor fati.)
Outcomes. You cannot guarantee you will never drink again. You can control today’s effort. (The reserve clause.)
Your body. You cannot control how long withdrawal lasts or how quickly sleep returns. You can control whether you get medical advice, eat properly, rest and give it time.
Why this is close to Step 1 and the Serenity Prayer
People in AA will recognise the shape of this. The Serenity Prayer asks for the serenity to accept what cannot be changed, the courage to change what can, and the wisdom to know the difference. Step 1 asks for an admission of powerlessness over alcohol.
Epictetus’s version adds a helpful precision. You may be powerless over the urge, the craving and much of your situation. You are not powerless over your next choice. Some people find that framing more workable than “powerlessness” alone: it is honest about the limits and clear about where your power lies. (Step 1 and Stoicism.)
The test for every thought
Epictetus did not leave the dichotomy as a theory. He made it a test to apply to every impression - every thought that arrives demanding to be believed:
“Straightway then practise saying to every harsh appearance, You are an appearance, and in no manner what you appear to be. Then examine it by the rules which you possess, and by this first and chiefly, whether it relates to the things which are in our power or to things which are not in our power”
I need a drink. Is that in my power? The feeling is not. The drinking is. They shouldn’t have said that to me. In my power? Their words, no. My response, yes. Over time, this becomes a habit of mind - a quick, steadying question you can ask about anything. (Testing impressions.)
A common misunderstanding
The dichotomy of control is sometimes misread as passivity: if it’s not in my control, I don’t need to care. That is not what Epictetus meant.
The point is to move your energy, not to withdraw it. You still care about your health, your relationships and your future. You simply put your effort into the part you can affect - your actions - rather than wasting it on the parts you cannot. If anything, it makes you more effective, because none of your effort is spent on fights you cannot win.
It is also not a way of avoiding responsibility. Your choices are in your power. That is exactly where responsibility lives.
Practices
- The two columns. When anything troubles you - an urge, a worry, a conflict - draw a line down a page. Not in my control / in my control. Fill both sides.
- One action. Pick one thing from the right-hand column and do it today.
- Let the left column rest. You do not have to solve it. You can leave it on the page.
- Ask the quick question. When a thought arrives, ask: “Is this in my power?” Make it a reflex.
- Review at night. Where did I spend energy on things outside my control today? Where could I have put it instead?
The control sorter on this site lets you type in what is worrying you and drag each part into “mine” or “not mine”. It saves only on your device. Many people find that seeing the two lists side by side changes how the whole situation feels. There is also a printable worksheet.
A foundation for everything else
Epictetus put this distinction at the very start of his handbook because everything else depends on it. Once you can tell what is yours and what is not, the rest of Stoic practice - testing impressions, accepting what happens, acting well in your roles - becomes much easier.
The Insight Tool uses “What is up to you” as one of its core angles. Whatever situation you choose, it will often bring you back here.
One thing for tonight
Before bed, pick one worry from today and sort it into the two columns. Leave the left-hand column on the page and take one small action from the right tomorrow.
Questions
What is the dichotomy of control?
A distinction taught by Epictetus between things that are within our power - our judgements, intentions, desires and actions - and things that are not - our body, possessions, reputation, other people and events. The Stoic practice is to put full effort into the first group and accept the second.
How does the dichotomy of control help with addiction?
It separates the urge, which you cannot stop from arriving, from your response, which you can choose. That narrows an overwhelming fight into one manageable task - what to do in the next few minutes. It also helps with things like other people’s drinking, the past and setbacks.
Is the dichotomy of control the same as the Serenity Prayer?
They express a very similar idea - accepting what you cannot change, changing what you can, and knowing the difference. The Serenity Prayer is a twentieth-century prayer; Epictetus wrote around nineteen centuries earlier.
Isn’t my drinking in my control?
Your actions are. But the urge, your history, your body’s reactions and many of your circumstances are not. Recognising that is not an excuse - it focuses your effort on the part you genuinely govern, which is your next choice.
Sources and further reading
- The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
- A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
- The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
- Epictetus Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Stoic Ethics Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Epictetus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.