Stoic concepts

Prosoche: the practice of attention

Many drinks are not decided. They happen on autopilot - the hand reaching for the fridge, the route past the shop, the “yes” before you have thought. The Stoics called the antidote prosoche - a steady attention to what you are doing and thinking. Epictetus devoted a whole discourse to it.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Stop for ten seconds and ask - what am I doing, what am I feeling, what am I thinking? Then decide what comes next on purpose.

The short version

  • Prosoche is Greek for “attention” - a continual watchfulness over your own thoughts, impressions and actions.
  • In his discourse On Attention, Epictetus warned that when attention lapses, “a habit of not attending is formed”, and that “Tomorrow I will begin to attend” really means “Today I will be shameless”.
  • Attention is what makes the other Stoic practices possible. You cannot test an impression you have not noticed.
  • In recovery, prosoche is the skill of catching the craving early - before it has become a decision.
  • It overlaps with modern mindfulness and urge-surfing approaches, though its purpose is ethical as well as calming.

Epictetus, “On Attention”

Near the end of the Discourses there is a short chapter with the title On Attention. It opens with a warning that anyone who has relapsed will recognise:

“When you have remitted your attention for a short time, do not imagine this, that you will recover it when you choose; but let this thought be present to you, that in consequence of the fault committed today your affairs must be in a worse condition for all that follows. For first, and what causes most trouble, a habit of not attending is formed in you; then a habit of deferring your attention.”

Epictetus’s point is that inattention is itself a habit. Let it slip once and it becomes easier to let it slip again. Then you start postponing - you will pay attention tomorrow, after this week, once things calm down.

He is blunt about that postponement:

“But now when you have said, Tomorrow I will begin to attend, you must be told that you are saying this, Today I will be shameless”

And he insists that attention belongs everywhere, including in play and pleasure:

“Today I choose to play. Well then, ought you not to play with attention? I choose to sing. What then hinders you from doing so with attention? Is there any part of life excepted, to which attention does not extend?”

Why attention comes first

Every other Stoic practice depends on attention. You cannot test an impression you have not noticed. You cannot apply the dichotomy of control to a worry that is running in the background. You cannot delay a pleasure you have already reached for.

Epictetus describes what happens without it:

“Do you not see that when you have let your mind loose, it is no longer in your power to recall it, either to propriety, or to modesty, or to moderation; but you do everything that comes into your mind in obedience to your inclinations.”

That is a fair description of autopilot drinking. The hand reaches for the bottle before the mind has caught up.

Autopilot and drinking

Habits, by definition, run with little conscious thought. That is useful when the habit is brushing your teeth. It is a problem when the habit is opening a bottle at 6pm.

People in recovery often describe drinks that seemed to happen before they had decided anything: walking into the shop on the way home, saying yes to a round, pouring a glass while cooking. Looking back, they can see the chain - the cue, the thought, the action - but at the time, each step went unnoticed.

Attention breaks the chain earlier. The aim is to notice:

  • the cue - the time of day, the place, the smell, the feeling
  • the first thought - “I could just…”, “it’s Friday”, “I deserve…”
  • the body - restlessness, tightness, a pull towards somewhere
  • the first step - changing route, opening the cupboard, picking up the phone to order

The earlier you notice, the more room you have. A craving caught at the cue is much easier to handle than one caught with a glass in your hand.

Prosoche and mindfulness

Modern psychology has developed approaches that look similar. Mindfulness-based relapse prevention and “urge surfing” teach people to notice cravings with curiosity, observing them rise and fall without acting on them. A 2023 review in Neurological Sciences pointed out the parallels between Roman Stoic practice and today’s mindfulness-based therapies.

There is a difference in emphasis. Mindfulness often stresses non-judgemental awareness - noticing without evaluating. Stoic attention is watchful in order to judge well. Epictetus wanted his students to notice impressions so they could examine them and choose how to act. In practice, the two fit together: notice without panic, then decide with care. (More on urge surfing.)

How to practise attention

1. Hourly check-ins

Set a gentle reminder a few times a day. When it goes off, ask three questions: What am I doing? What am I feeling? What am I thinking? Ten seconds is enough. Over time, the habit of checking in starts to happen without the reminder.

2. Know your cues

Write down the times, places, people and feelings most linked with drinking for you. Knowing them in advance makes them easier to spot. The HALT check-in is a quick way to check four of the most common states - hungry, angry, lonely, tired.

3. Name it

When you notice an urge, name it out loud or in your head: “There’s the 6pm thing.” “That’s the smell of the pub.” “That’s the ‘I deserve it’ thought.” Naming moves you from inside the urge to watching it.

4. Slow down the first step

Many drinks start with a small, automatic step. Make that step deliberate. If you notice yourself heading towards the shop, stop on the pavement and take three breaths before deciding which way to go.

5. Attend to small things

Epictetus thought attention should extend to every part of life - play, work, conversation. Practise on ordinary tasks: wash up with full attention, walk without your phone, eat one meal slowly. It strengthens the same muscle you need for cravings.

6. Review the day

Seneca’s evening review is attention looking backwards. Each night, ask where your attention slipped and what happened when it did. Patterns appear quickly.

When attention slips

It will. Epictetus did not expect perfection:

“What then? is it possible to be free from faults (if you do all this)? It is not possible; but this is possible, to direct your efforts incessantly to being faultless. For we must be content if by never remitting this attention we shall escape at least a few errors.”

The goal is not flawless watchfulness. It is to keep returning - to notice that you drifted, and come back. Every return strengthens the habit, just as every lapse, in Epictetus’s warning, strengthens the habit of not attending.

A short practice for tonight

  1. Sit down and take five slow breaths.
  2. Notice what you can feel in your body, without changing it.
  3. Notice what you are thinking - just the headline.
  4. Notice what you want right now.
  5. Ask: is this want mine to act on, or an impression to examine?

It takes two minutes. Do it at the time of day your cravings usually arrive, and you will start to catch them earlier.

The Insight Tool is also, in a sense, an attention exercise: describing what is happening in your own words is one of the quickest ways to step out of autopilot and look at the moment clearly.

One thing for tonight

Set a reminder for the time your cravings usually start, with one word on it - “Notice.”

Questions

What is prosoche?

Prosoche is an ancient Greek word for attention. In Stoicism it describes a continual, alert awareness of your own mind - your impressions, judgements, desires and actions - so that you can act deliberately rather than on autopilot.

Is prosoche the same as mindfulness?

They overlap. Both involve paying close attention to present experience, and a 2023 review noted parallels between Stoic practice and modern mindfulness-based therapies. But Stoic attention has an explicitly ethical aim - noticing impressions so you can judge them and act well - whereas mindfulness often emphasises non-judgemental awareness.

How does attention help with cravings?

Most cravings are easier to manage early, before they have built momentum or been acted on automatically. Attention helps you notice the first signs - the restlessness, the thought, the cue - while you still have room to choose.

Sources and further reading

  1. A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
  2. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  3. Epictetus Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  4. Epictetus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  5. Surfing the urge: brief mindfulness-based intervention for college student smokers Bowen and Marlatt, Psychology of Addictive Behaviors (2009)An early trial of “urge surfing” - noticing cravings without acting on them (in smokers).
  6. The Western origins of mindfulness therapy in ancient Rome Cavanna and colleagues, Neurological Sciences (2023)A review noting that Stoic philosophy has multiple parallels with cognitive behavioural therapy.

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.