Understanding your drinking

Why willpower doesn’t work

Many people try to stop drinking by sheer force of will - and many find that, sooner or later, the will gives way. That is not a character flaw. It is a sign that willpower alone, used at the worst possible moment, is the wrong tool for the job.

risespeakspasses

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Make one change today that means you need less willpower tonight - pour away the alcohol in the house, change your route home, or plan the hour you usually drink.

The short version

  • Willpower means overriding a strong urge in the moment. It is hardest exactly when urges are strongest - when you are tired, stressed, hungry or upset.
  • Relying on willpower alone puts you in a fight you have to win every single time.
  • What works better is acting earlier - changing your environment, planning for high-risk situations, building new habits and getting support. These are the core of relapse prevention.
  • Epictetus treated habits as things that grow when fed and weaken when starved - a matter of training, not heroics.
  • Seneca advised avoiding situations that unsettle new habits while they are young. Avoiding temptation is not weakness; it is strategy.

You decide in the morning: not tonight. You mean it. You feel strong. Then the evening comes - a hard day, a quiet house, a familiar time - and the decision you made so firmly at breakfast seems to belong to someone else. You drink. And then, on top of everything, you feel weak.

If that has happened to you, it helps to know that it happens to almost everyone who relies on willpower alone. The problem is not that you lack character. It is that you are using the wrong tool at the wrong moment.

Pause here for a moment. Breathe in as the circle grows and out as it shrinks. Three slow breaths is enough. The rest of the page will wait.

What willpower is, and when it fails

Willpower, in the everyday sense, is overriding an urge in the moment - deciding not to do something you strongly want to do, while you want to do it.

It has a basic weakness: it has to be used exactly when it is hardest. Urges to drink are strongest when you are tired, stressed, hungry, lonely, upset or surrounded by cues - which are also the times your ability to reason and resist is lowest. You are asking yourself to make your best decision at your worst moment.

It also has to win every time. Relying on willpower alone means facing every evening, every party, every hard day as a fresh fight. Lose once, and the habit gets a little stronger again.

None of this means willpower is useless. It means it should be the last line of defence, not the only one.

Remember

If willpower has failed you before, that is not evidence that you cannot stop. It is evidence that you need more than willpower - which is true of nearly everyone.

What works better

The approach known as relapse prevention, developed by the psychologist Alan Marlatt and colleagues, puts much less weight on resisting in the moment and much more on what happens before and around it. Its main strategies include identifying high-risk situations, building coping skills for them, managing urges, controlling exposure to cues, and creating a balanced lifestyle. (Relapse prevention.)

In plain terms, that means four things.

Change your environment

Every bottle in the house is a decision you have to make again every evening. Remove it, and the decision mostly disappears. Change the route that takes you past the off-licence. Rearrange the chair you always drink in. Make the easy path the sober one.

Plan for the hard moments

Most drinking happens in predictable situations - certain times, places, people, feelings. Decide in a calm hour what you will do in each. Then, in the moment, you are following a plan rather than wrestling with an urge. (Rehearsing hard moments.)

Build new habits

A habit is not broken by fighting it forever. It fades when it goes unfed, and is replaced by another. If 6pm used to mean a drink, it can come to mean a walk, a shower, a call or a particular non-alcoholic drink. The new habit takes the weight off willpower.

Get support

Other people make an enormous difference. A friend you can text, a group you attend, a sponsor or counsellor - each one means you are not relying on your own resolve alone.

The Stoic view: training, not heroics

The Stoics are sometimes imagined as people of iron will, gritting their teeth through every hardship. That is not really how they described their own practice. They talked about training - steady, daily practice that made right action easier over time.

Habits grow on what feeds them

Epictetus put it simply:

“Every habit and faculty is maintained and increased by the corresponding actions: the habit of walking by walking, the habit of running by running.”
Epictetus, Discourses 2.18

He went on to describe overcoming anger not by a single heroic effort, but by counting the days without it - every day, then every second day, then every third - until the habit weakened and was “completely destroyed”. That is not willpower. It is patient starvation of a habit, one day at a time.

Avoid what unsettles you

Seneca, writing to a friend working on his character, gave advice that runs directly against the willpower approach:

“Do you ask me what you should regard as especially to be avoided? I say, crowds; for as yet you cannot trust yourself to them with safety.”
Seneca, Letters 7

He admitted that he himself never came home from a crowd with the same character he took out. Seneca did not think the answer was to walk into temptation and resist it. He thought the wise thing, while new habits are young, is to stay away from what unsettles them. In recovery, that might mean avoiding certain pubs, parties or people for a while. That is not weakness. It is strategy.

Delay instead of fight

Epictetus’s advice for any tempting pleasure was not “resist” but “delay”: “let the affair wait your leisure, and procure yourself some delay.” Delay takes much less effort than refusal, and urges usually fade with time. (Urge surfing.)

Accept help

Marcus Aurelius, the most powerful man in the world, wrote to himself: “Be not ashamed to be helped.” He compared himself to a soldier who cannot climb a wall alone but can with help. The goal is to get over the wall - not to prove you can do it unaided.

Practices that save your willpower

Six ways to need less willpower
  1. Clear the house. Remove alcohol from your home. If others drink there, ask for it to be kept out of sight.
  2. Plan your danger hour. Decide exactly what you will do at the time you usually drink, and set it up in advance.
  3. Look after the basics. Eat regularly, sleep enough and do not let yourself get too tired. Hungry, angry, lonely and tired are the states where willpower runs out fastest. (HALT.)
  4. Delay, do not debate. When an urge comes, set a timer for twenty minutes instead of arguing with yourself. Use the Urge Timer.
  5. Replace the ritual. Keep the shape of the old habit - the time, the glass, the chair - and change what goes in it.
  6. Line up people. Know who you can message when the evening gets hard, and when your next meeting is.
Before the moment, not in it

Look at the week ahead and find the three moments when your willpower is most likely to run out - a Friday, a family visit, a late night at work. For each, write one thing you will do before you get there: eat, plan, leave early, bring a friend, not go. That page will do more than any amount of resolve.

It does get easier

The good news about habits is that they work in both directions. Each time an urge passes without a drink, the link weakens a little. Many people find that after some weeks and months, urges come less often and pass more quickly. What once took all your willpower starts to need very little.

If you have tried and failed many times on willpower alone, that is a reason to try a different approach - not to give up. Your GP, a local alcohol service, AA or SMART Recovery can all help you build the kind of support that makes willpower less necessary.

One thing for tonight

Write down the three moments this week when your willpower is most likely to run out. For each, write one thing you can do before you get there.

Questions

Why can’t I just use willpower to stop drinking?

You can, sometimes - but willpower alone is unreliable, because it has to win in the moments when urges are strongest and your resources are lowest. Most people do better when they combine it with changes to their environment, plans for high-risk situations, new habits and support.

Does needing help mean I’m weak?

No. People who stay sober long-term rarely rely on willpower alone. They change what is around them, plan ahead and lean on others. Marcus Aurelius, emperor of Rome, wrote to himself, “Be not ashamed to be helped.”

What works better than willpower?

Removing alcohol from your home, avoiding or planning for high-risk situations, delaying when urges arrive, replacing drinking routines with new ones, looking after sleep and food, and having people to call. These reduce how often you need to rely on willpower at all.

Will it always be this hard?

For most people, no. Each time an urge passes without a drink, the habit weakens a little. Over weeks and months, urges usually become less frequent and less intense.

Sources and further reading

  1. Relapse prevention: an overview of Marlatt’s cognitive-behavioral model Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, Alcohol Research & Health (1999)High-risk situations, coping skills, urge management and the “abstinence violation effect” after a lapse.
  2. Surfing the urge: brief mindfulness-based intervention for college student smokers Bowen and Marlatt, Psychology of Addictive Behaviors (2009)An early trial of “urge surfing” - noticing cravings without acting on them (in smokers).
  3. Tips on cutting down on alcohol NHS
  4. A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
  5. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  6. Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource
  7. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.