The Stoics, in their own words

Seneca on anger and alcohol

Seneca wrote three books about anger - not because he had mastered it, but because he had seen what it did, in himself and in the most powerful men in Rome. He also wrote one of the sharpest pieces on drunkenness ever written. Together they make a surprisingly practical guide for anyone whose anger and drinking feed each other.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

When anger rises, give it the one thing Seneca asked for - time. Say nothing, send nothing and drink nothing for the next hour, and move your body while you wait.

The short version

  • Seneca called anger “a short madness” - deaf to reason, quick to act, and destructive to the person who carries it.
  • He described anger in three stages - an involuntary first jolt, a judgement that we have been wronged, and an anger that overrides reason. The middle stage is where we have a choice.
  • His first and greatest remedy was delay - “if it delays, it will come to an end”.
  • He tells the story of King Cambyses, a heavy drinker who killed a friend’s son to prove that wine did not affect him - an example of how drink and anger combine.
  • His nightly review of the day - examining himself without cruelty - is one of the most useful habits he left.

Lucius Annaeus Seneca lived close to power for most of his life. He was a senator, a playwright, one of the richest men in Rome and, for years, tutor and adviser to the emperor Nero. He saw anger at its most dangerous - in men who could have someone killed on a whim - and he wrote about it at length in a three-book essay, On Anger, addressed to his brother Novatus.

He also wrote, late in life, a letter to his friend Lucilius about drunkenness. Read together, they describe a pattern many people in recovery will recognise: anger and alcohol making each other worse.

Pause here for a moment. Breathe in as the circle grows and out as it shrinks. Three slow breaths is enough. The rest of the page will wait.

Anger as “a short madness”

Seneca opens On Anger with a portrait of the angry person - the flushed face, the trembling lips, the clenched hands - and then a verdict:

“Some of the wisest of men have in consequence of this called anger a short madness: for it is equally devoid of self control, regardless of decorum, forgetful of kinship, obstinately engrossed in whatever it begins to do, deaf to reason and advice, excited by trifling causes, awkward at perceiving what is true and just, and very like a falling rock which breaks itself to pieces upon the very thing which it crushes.”
Seneca, On Anger 1.1

That last image is worth holding on to. Anger, Seneca says, is like a falling rock: it smashes itself on whatever it hits. The angry person is usually the one most damaged.

Seneca disagreed with those who thought anger could be useful - as a spur to justice, or courage in battle. A good person, he argued, can protect and avenge without being angry, and will do it better, because anger makes judgement worse.

The three stages of anger

Seneca’s most useful insight is a description of how anger takes hold. He describes three stages:

“…learn that the first emotion is involuntary, and is, as it were, a preparation for a passion, and a threatening of one. The next is combined with a wish, though not an obstinate one… The third emotion is already beyond our control, because it overrides reason, and wishes to avenge itself, not if it be its duty, but whether or no.”
Seneca, On Anger 2.4

In plain terms:

  1. The jolt. Someone says something cutting, and you feel the flash - heat, tension, a racing heart. Seneca says we cannot prevent this, any more than we can stop ourselves yawning when someone else yawns.
  2. The judgement. A thought follows: I have been wronged. They should pay for that. This is still a thought, and it can still be examined.
  3. The takeover. If we agree with the judgement, anger takes over and acts “whether or no” - whatever reason says.

The practical lesson is that the middle stage is where your power lies. You cannot stop the jolt. You can catch the judgement before it becomes the takeover - and, for someone in recovery, before it becomes a drink.

Wine and anger: the story of Cambyses

In the third book of On Anger, Seneca tells a chilling story about the Persian king Cambyses, who “was excessively addicted to wine”. A friend, Praexaspes, advised him to drink less, pointing out how shameful drunkenness was in a king. Cambyses replied that he would prove he never lost command of himself. He drank more than usual and then, “heavy and besotted with wine”, shot an arrow through the heart of Praexaspes’s son to show how steady his hand was.

It is an extreme story, told for effect. But Seneca’s point is a familiar one: the person who insists that drink does not affect them is often the person most affected. And drink combined with anger, wounded pride and power produces things that cannot be undone.

In his Letter 83, Seneca generalises the point:

“Drunkenness kindles and discloses every kind of vice, and removes the sense of shame that veils our evil undertakings.”
Seneca, Letters 83

A little later he writes that “cruelty usually follows wine-bibbing”, and that when people are often beside themselves, “the habit of madness lasts on”. Anyone who has watched their temper shorten as the evening went on - or felt it stay short in early sobriety - will know what he means. (What the Stoics said about wine.)

Seneca’s remedies

Delay

Seneca’s first and greatest remedy is simple:

“The greatest remedy for anger is delay: beg anger to grant you this at the first, not in order that it may pardon the offence, but that it may form a right judgment about it: if it delays, it will come to an end.”
Seneca, On Anger 2.29

Delay gives the second stage time to be examined. It also works on cravings. An urge to drink that arrives on a wave of anger will usually fade as the anger does, if you give it time.

Look at your own faults

Seneca repeatedly reminds his reader that we are all capable of the things that anger us in others. Marcus Aurelius, who read Seneca’s generation of Stoics closely, made the same point in his own list of remedies for anger: consider that you too do many things wrong. This is not about letting people off. It takes the self-righteousness out of anger - and self-righteousness is often what makes a drink feel justified.

Avoid what provokes you

Seneca was practical: if certain situations reliably make you angry, avoid them while you are learning, and do not take on more than you can handle. In recovery, that might mean steering clear of certain conversations, people or places for a while, especially when tired or hungry.

The evening review

Perhaps Seneca’s best-known habit appears near the end of On Anger:

“…when the lamp is taken out of my sight, and my wife, who knows my habit, has ceased to talk, I pass the whole day in review before myself, and repeat all that I have said and done: I conceal nothing from myself, and omit nothing”
Seneca, On Anger 3.36

He goes on to say that he does not fear his shortcomings, because he can say to himself, “I pardon you this time: see that you never do that anymore.” The review is honest without being cruel - a combination many people in recovery find hard and valuable. It is a close ancestor of Step 10 of the 12 Steps, the continued personal inventory. (The evening review.)

Using Seneca when anger and drinking meet

A Senecan plan for angry evenings
  1. Notice the jolt, and name it. “That’s the first stage. I didn’t choose it.” Naming it creates a little distance.
  2. Catch the judgement. Write down the thought that followed: “They humiliated me and I should…” Ask whether it is the whole truth.
  3. Delay everything. No messages, no decisions, no drink for at least an hour. Seneca’s “beg anger to grant you this at the first”.
  4. Move. Walk, run, climb stairs. Let the body come down.
  5. Review at night. When the lights are off, go through the day: where was I angry, what set it off, what would I do differently? Then pardon yourself, and sleep.
One question for the second stage

When the judgement arrives - they deserve this, I deserve a drink - ask: “If I were watching someone else in this situation, what would I hope they did?” Seneca advised imagining a person you respect watching you. Their steadiness is often easier to borrow than to summon.

A note on Seneca himself

Seneca was not a saint, and he did not pretend to be. He was enormously wealthy while praising simplicity, and he served an emperor who became notorious for cruelty. Critics in his own time and since have pointed this out. Seneca’s own reply, in several places, was that he was not a wise man but someone trying to improve - writing, as he said elsewhere, as a patient in the same hospital as his reader.

That is part of why he is useful in recovery. He knew anger from the inside. His remedies are the remedies of someone who needed them.

The Insight Tool uses Seneca’s ideas on anger in its angles “The cost of anger” and “People will be people”, especially for arguments and conflict at work.

One thing for tonight

Try Seneca’s evening review - when the lights are off, go through the day and ask where you were angry, what set it off, and what you would do differently. Then pardon yourself and sleep.

Questions

What did Seneca say about anger?

In his three-book work On Anger, Seneca argued that anger is never truly useful, that it distorts judgement, and that it harms the angry person more than its target. He called it a short madness, described how it builds in stages, and recommended delay, self-examination and avoiding situations that provoke it.

Did Seneca write about alcohol?

Yes. His Letter 83 is an extended attack on drunkenness, which he called “a condition of insanity purposely assumed”. He argued that drink does not create vices but brings them into view - including anger and cruelty. On Anger also includes stories of rulers whose drinking made their anger deadly.

What are Seneca’s three stages of anger?

First, an involuntary emotional jolt we cannot prevent. Second, a judgement - “I have been wronged and should get revenge” - which we can still examine. Third, an anger that “overrides reason” and acts regardless. The practical lesson is to catch anger at the second stage.

What is Seneca’s evening review?

A nightly habit he describes in On Anger. After the lamp was out, he went through the whole day, examining what he had said and done, concealing nothing - then pardoned himself and resolved to do better. It is a precursor of Step 10 in the 12 Steps and of modern reflective journaling.

Sources and further reading

  1. Seneca’s Minor Dialogues (including On Anger and On the Shortness of Life), translated by Aubrey Stewart Project Gutenberg eBook 64576
  2. Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource
  3. Seneca Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  4. Seneca, Lucius Annaeus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  5. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.