Stoic concepts

Amor fati: working with what has happened

A lot of the pain in recovery is an argument with the past - the years lost, the things said, the slip last week. The Stoics taught a way of ending that argument without pretending the past was fine. It is usually called amor fati, and it is easy to misunderstand.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

When you catch yourself arguing with something that has already happened, finish the sentence “It has happened, and…” with something you can do.

The short version

  • The phrase “amor fati” (love of fate) comes from the nineteenth-century philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, not the ancient Stoics. But the idea behind it is deeply Stoic.
  • Epictetus advised wanting things to happen as they do happen. Marcus Aurelius wrote that the mind turns every hindrance into an aid, and pictured himself as a headland that the waves break against.
  • Acceptance is not approval. You can accept that something happened and still wish it had not, and still work to put it right.
  • In recovery, this ends the exhausting argument with the past - and moves the energy to what can still be done.
  • {’It applies to slips too’: ‘arguing with a relapse feeds shame; accepting it makes room to return.’}

Where the phrase comes from

It is worth being accurate here, because many websites are not. The phrase amor fati - “love of fate” - does not appear in the ancient Stoics. It was made famous by Friedrich Nietzsche, who wrote in the 1880s that his formula for greatness was to want nothing to be different, “not forward, not backward, not in all eternity”.

Nietzsche was not a Stoic, and he criticised the Stoics in other places. But the attitude he named is one the Stoics had described many centuries earlier. When people talk about “Stoic amor fati”, they mean that attitude, and it is worth looking at what the Stoics themselves actually wrote.

What the Stoics wrote

Epictetus: want what happens

The most direct statement is in Epictetus’s Enchiridion:

“Seek not that the things which happen should happen as you wish; but wish the things which happen to be as they are, and you will have a tranquil flow of life.”

Notice the order. First, stop demanding that the world match your wishes. Second, go further: actively want things to be as they are. Epictetus thought most unhappiness came from the gap between what we want and what is. Close the gap from your side, and the unhappiness goes.

Marcus: everything is fruit

Marcus Aurelius wrote with real feeling about accepting the course of things:

“Everything harmonizes with me, which is harmonious to thee, O Universe. Nothing for me is too early nor too late, which is in due time for thee. Everything is fruit to me which thy seasons bring, O Nature”

For Marcus, a Stoic who believed the universe was rationally ordered, this was a religious attitude as much as a practical one. You do not have to share his view of the universe to use the practical part: everything that happens can become material for living well.

The headland

Marcus’s most memorable image of acceptance is a headland in the sea:

“Be like the promontory against which the waves continually break, but it stands firm and tames the fury of the water around it.”

He goes on: “Unhappy am I because this has happened to me? Not so, but happy am I, though this has happened to me, because I continue free from pain, neither crushed by the present nor fearing the future.”

The headland does not argue with the waves. They keep coming. It simply stands, and the water around it calms.

The obstacle becomes the way

And there is the passage that has become famous in modern self-help:

”…for the mind converts and changes every hindrance to its activity into an aid; and so that which is a hindrance is made a furtherance to an act; and that which is an obstacle on the road helps us on this road.”

This is the active side of acceptance. Not only do you stop fighting the obstacle - you use it.

Acceptance is not approval

The biggest misunderstanding of this idea is that it means being happy about bad things, or pretending they do not matter. That is not what the Stoics meant, and it would be a harmful way to approach recovery.

Accepting that something happened means:

  • recognising that it is real and cannot be undone
  • no longer spending energy wishing it had not happened
  • turning your attention to what you can do now

It does not mean:

  • that it was good
  • that you do not regret it
  • that you should not make amends
  • that you should not feel sad, angry or ashamed for a while

Think of grief. A person who has lost someone does not stop missing them. But at some point they stop arguing with the fact of the death, and that is when they can start to live again. That is the kind of acceptance the Stoics meant.

The argument with the past

Many people in recovery carry an exhausting argument with their own history:

  • “I can’t believe I wasted all those years.”
  • “If only I’d stopped sooner.”
  • “I should never have said that to her.”
  • “Why did I drink last Saturday when I was doing so well?”

Each of these is an argument with something that has already happened. The argument can run for hours, and it rarely changes anything except how bad you feel. Worse, it often feeds the very drinking it regrets. Shame and regret are among the most common triggers there are.

Stoic acceptance offers a way out. Not by saying the regret is wrong, but by changing the question. Instead of “why did this happen?” or “how could I?”, the question becomes “given that this happened, what now?”.

That is also, in effect, what the 12 Steps ask in their later stages. You take an honest inventory of the past, admit it, and make amends where you can. Then you live differently. The past is not erased. It becomes the starting point. (This site’s Step 3 page explores the Stoic reading of “turning it over”.)

After a slip

Acceptance matters most after a relapse.

When someone in recovery drinks again, the first reaction is often a fierce argument with what happened: “I can’t believe I’ve done this. I’ve ruined everything. I’m hopeless.” Relapse researchers call one version of this the abstinence violation effect: the belief that one drink has destroyed everything, which makes carrying on drinking feel almost logical.

The Stoic response is not to pretend the slip was fine. It is to accept that it happened - fully, without arguing - so that you can look at it clearly and take the next step. Marcus wrote to himself:

“Be not disgusted, nor discouraged, nor dissatisfied, if you do not succeed in doing everything according to right principles, but when you have failed, return back again”

No disgust. No argument. Return. (What to do after a relapse.)

How to practise it

Finish the sentence

When you notice yourself arguing with something that has happened, write: “It has happened, and…” - and finish the sentence three times with something you can do. “It has happened, and I can tell my sponsor.” “It has happened, and I can apologise.” “It has happened, and I can go to bed and start again tomorrow.”

Use the obstacle

Ask: what could this difficulty train in me? Patience, honesty, asking for help, sitting with discomfort? Then do one small thing that practises that quality.

Stand like the headland

When feelings come in waves, picture the headland. You do not need to stop the waves. You only need to stand. Breathe slowly, let each wave come and go, and notice that you are still standing when it passes.

Separate the fact from the story

Write the fact in one plain sentence: “I drank on Saturday.” Then write the story you are telling about it: “I’m a failure and I’ll never stop.” The fact must be accepted. The story can be questioned. (More on testing impressions.)

A caution

Acceptance is for things that have already happened or genuinely cannot be changed. It is not a reason to put up with things you can and should change - an unsafe situation, a harmful relationship, untreated illness, drinking that is still going on. The Stoic distinction between what is and is not in our control cuts both ways: accept what you cannot change, and act on what you can.

If you are in a situation where you are being harmed, please seek help. And if regret about the past is weighing on you so heavily that it is affecting your daily life, talk to your GP or a counsellor.

Amor fati works together with the reserve clause (holding your plans with a condition attached) and premeditatio malorum (rehearsing difficulties in advance). Before, during and after: prepare, commit with a reservation, and accept what comes.

The Insight Tool uses two angles drawn from this page - “Work with what is” and “The obstacle as material” - especially for slips, grief, rejection and plans that have fallen apart.

One thing for tonight

Write the plain fact of one regret in a sentence, then the story you tell about it. Keep the fact; question the story.

Questions

Is amor fati a Stoic phrase?

No. The Latin phrase amor fati, “love of fate”, was popularised by Friedrich Nietzsche in the 1880s. The ancient Stoics did not use it. But it captures a central Stoic attitude - accepting and even embracing what happens - which appears throughout Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius.

Does amor fati mean I have to love the bad things that happened?

Not in the sense of being glad about them. The Stoic idea is closer to wholehearted acceptance - stopping the fight with what has already happened so you can respond well. You can grieve, regret and make amends while still accepting that it happened.

How does this help after a relapse?

After a slip, the mind often argues with what happened - “I can’t believe I did that”, “I’ve ruined everything”. That argument feeds shame, and shame feeds drinking. Accepting that the slip happened, without approving of it, makes it possible to look at it calmly and take the next step.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  2. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  3. Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  4. Marcus Aurelius Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  5. Stoic Ethics Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.