Stoicism and CBT: the shared roots, and how to use both
Cognitive behavioural therapy is one of the main talking treatments for drinking problems, and it owes a debt to the Stoics. Knowing where the two meet - and where they part - can make each of them more useful to you.
Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone
If you only do one thing
Catch the next thought that pushes you towards a drink, write it in quotation marks, and ask - what is the evidence for this, and what is it leaving out?
The short version
- CBT and Stoicism share one central idea - that our judgements about events, more than the events themselves, shape how we feel and act. Epictetus put it in one line nearly two thousand years ago.
- The founders of modern cognitive therapy, Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck, both acknowledged the Stoics as philosophical forerunners.
- CBT is a recommended treatment for drinking problems. In the UK, NICE advises offering psychological interventions such as CBT for harmful drinking and mild dependence, and the NHS provides CBT free.
- Stoicism adds what a course of therapy usually does not - a whole philosophy of life, a set of values to aim at, and daily practices to keep going after therapy ends.
- Stoicism is not a substitute for treatment. The two work best together.
One sentence, two thousand years apart
Around a hundred years after the birth of Christ, a former slave called Epictetus was teaching philosophy in north-western Greece. His student Arrian wrote down his teachings, and the short handbook made from them - the Enchiridion - contains this line:
“Men are disturbed not by things, but by the views which they take of things.”
In the 1950s, the American psychologist Albert Ellis built a new kind of therapy on the same idea. He called it rational emotive behaviour therapy, and he often quoted Epictetus when explaining it. A few years later, the psychiatrist Aaron Beck developed cognitive therapy. In their 1979 book Cognitive Therapy of Depression, Beck and his colleagues traced the philosophical origins of their approach to the Stoic philosophers. Together, these two strands became much of what we now call cognitive behavioural therapy, or CBT.
That does not make CBT ancient, or Stoicism a therapy. CBT also draws on behavioural psychology and decades of clinical research, and it has been tested in trials in a way no philosophy has. But the shared root explains why people who find CBT helpful often feel at home with the Stoics, and the other way round. A 2023 review in Neurological Sciences put it simply: Stoic philosophy “has multiple parallels with cognitive behavioural therapy interventions”.
The core idea they share
The central claim of both is that emotions and actions are shaped not only by what happens to us, but by how we interpret it.
Marcus Aurelius wrote to himself:
“If you are pained by any external thing, it is not this thing that disturbs you, but your own judgement about it. And it is in your power to wipe out this judgement now.”
CBT puts the same idea in a diagram. A situation triggers automatic thoughts. Those thoughts produce feelings, physical sensations and urges. The urges lead to behaviour, and the behaviour feeds back into the situation. Change the thoughts and you can change the rest of the cycle.
Here is how that looks with drinking:
| Example | |
|---|---|
| Situation | Your manager criticises a piece of work late on a Friday. |
| Automatic thought | “I’m useless. I can’t do anything right. I need a drink to get through tonight.” |
| Feeling | Shame, anxiety, a tight chest. |
| Urge | Strong pull to buy wine on the way home. |
| Behaviour | Drinking, which brings relief for an hour, then worse sleep and more anxiety the next day. |
Neither CBT nor Stoicism asks you to pretend the criticism did not happen or did not hurt. Both ask you to look closely at the step in the middle - the thought - because that is where you have room to act.
Where the methods line up
The overlap goes beyond the core idea. Many specific CBT techniques have close Stoic equivalents.
Questioning automatic thoughts / testing impressions
CBT teaches you to catch automatic thoughts and ask: what is the evidence for this? Is there another way to see it? What would I say to a friend who thought this?
Epictetus taught his students to do the same with what he called impressions:
“Straightway then practise saying to every harsh appearance, You are an appearance, and in no manner what you appear to be. Then examine it by the rules which you possess…”
“I need a drink to get through tonight” is an impression. It arrives looking like a fact. Both traditions ask you to examine it before you act on it. The Insight Tool has a questions mode built on exactly this.
Thinking errors / adding to it in imagination
CBT names common thinking errors: catastrophising, all-or-nothing thinking, mind-reading, fortune-telling. The Stoics did not use the same labels, but they described the same habits. Marcus wrote that pain is bearable “if you bear in mind that it has its limits, and if you add nothing to it in imagination”. Seneca observed that “we suffer more often in imagination than in reality”.
“I’ve had a drink, so I’ve ruined everything” is all-or-nothing thinking. Researchers in relapse prevention call the version that follows a slip the abstinence violation effect: the belief that one drink means total failure, which can turn a lapse into a full relapse. Marcus’s answer to his own failures was the same as a good therapist’s: no disgust, and return to the path. (More on what to do after a relapse.)
Thought records / the evening review
A thought record is a CBT worksheet where you write down a situation, your thoughts, your feelings and a more balanced view. Seneca did something similar every night:
”…when the lamp is taken out of my sight, and my wife, who knows my habit, has ceased to talk, I pass the whole day in review before myself, and repeat all that I have said and done”
The Stoic evening review is less structured than a thought record, but the purpose is the same: to look at your reactions calmly, after the heat has gone, and learn from them. The evening review tool on this site keeps your answers on your own device.
Coping plans / premeditatio malorum
CBT-based relapse prevention spends a lot of time on high-risk situations: identifying them in advance and planning how to cope. The Stoics called this premeditatio malorum - rehearsing difficulties before they happen. Seneca wrote that “nothing ought to be unexpected by us”, and that our minds should be sent ahead to meet problems.
Planning what you will say when offered a drink at a wedding, or what you will do at 6pm on a Friday, is the same exercise under either name. The urge plan worksheet puts it on paper.
Behavioural experiments / voluntary discomfort
CBT encourages you to test beliefs in practice. “I can’t enjoy a party without drinking” can be tested by going to one sober and seeing what actually happens. The Stoics practised voluntary discomfort for similar reasons: to discover that what they feared was more bearable than they thought.
What CBT for drinking involves
If you see a therapist for CBT about alcohol, the work usually includes:
- Understanding your pattern - when, where and why you drink, and what drinking does for you.
- Identifying triggers and high-risk situations - people, places, feelings and times.
- Working with thoughts - catching and questioning the thoughts that lead towards drinking (“I deserve it”, “just one won’t hurt”).
- Building coping skills - for urges, stress, social pressure and difficult emotions.
- Planning for setbacks - so that a slip does not become a relapse.
Many of these elements come from the relapse prevention model developed by Alan Marlatt and colleagues, which focuses on high-risk situations, coping skills and how people respond to lapses.
In England, NICE guidance recommends offering a psychological intervention, such as cognitive behavioural therapies, to people who are drinking harmfully or are mildly dependent on alcohol. The NHS lists problems with alcohol among the conditions CBT can help with, and you can often refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies or ask your GP. In other countries, your doctor or local alcohol service can tell you what is available.
If you are drinking heavily every day, talk to a doctor before stopping. Therapy is not a replacement for medical care where that is needed.
Where Stoicism adds something different
If CBT already has these techniques and the evidence behind them, what does Stoicism add? Several things, and they are not small.
A reason, not just a technique
CBT is deliberately practical. It helps you notice and change unhelpful patterns. Stoicism asks a bigger question: what is a good life, and what kind of person do you want to be?
For many people in recovery, that question matters enormously. Not drinking leaves a gap: in time, in identity, in purpose. CBT can help you handle urges. Stoicism offers something to aim at - the four virtues of wisdom, courage, justice and self-control - and a reason to keep going when the urges are gone but life still feels flat.
Values, not just accuracy
CBT often asks whether a thought is accurate or helpful. Stoicism adds a third question: is it worthy of you?
“Everyone else is drinking, so why shouldn’t I?” may be perfectly accurate. It may even feel helpful in the moment. The Stoic question is whether acting on it fits the person you are trying to be. Epictetus taught his students to measure their actions against their roles - as a parent, a friend, a citizen. That is a different and sometimes stronger form of motivation.
Something that lasts after therapy ends
A course of CBT has a beginning and an end, and NHS courses are often fairly short. Stoicism is designed to be practised for life. The morning preparation, the evening review and daily reading are habits that can carry on long after sessions finish. That is one reason this site offers a daily reading for every day of the year.
A community of writers
CBT comes in worksheets. Stoicism comes in some of the finest writing in the Western tradition. Many people find that reading Marcus, Seneca and Epictetus gives them a sense of company - other people, long ago, struggling with anger, fear, desire and failure, and writing honestly about it.
Where Stoicism falls short
It is worth being clear about the limits too.
- It is not a treatment. No trial has tested Stoicism as a treatment for alcohol problems. CBT has a substantial body of research behind it. If you need treatment, get treatment.
- It can be misused. Stoicism is sometimes misunderstood as “suppress your feelings” or “tough it out alone”. That is not what the Stoics taught, and it is a dangerous way to approach recovery. Marcus wrote: “Be not ashamed to be helped.”
- It does not handle withdrawal or medical risk. Heavy, daily drinking can carry serious medical risks when you stop. That is a job for doctors, not philosophers.
- It needs translating. The ancient texts use unfamiliar language and assume an ancient world. Modern guides - including the pages on this site - try to bridge that gap, but some of the translation is interpretation.
Using both together
You do not have to choose. Here is a practical way to combine them.
1. Get the evidence-based help first. If your drinking is causing problems, speak to your GP, an alcohol service, or a support group. Ask about CBT. If you are in the UK, the NHS alcohol support page lists the main options.
2. Use Stoic practices to reinforce what you learn. If your therapist asks you to keep a thought record, try adding a Stoic column: “What is in my control here?” or “What would the person I want to be do next?”.
3. Use the Stoics for the long term. When therapy finishes, keep the habits going: morning preparation, evening review, a daily passage. Many people find the philosophy gives them a reason to continue that worksheets alone do not.
4. Use the tools in the moment. When an urge arrives, the Urge Timer, the Insight Tool and the HALT check-in are built on the same principles CBT and Stoicism share.
A Stoic thought record
Here is a simple thought record that combines both approaches. Try it next time you notice a strong urge to drink.
- Situation. What happened? Just the facts.
- Impression. What thought came with it? Write it in quotation marks, exactly as it appeared.
- Feeling and urge. What did you feel, and how strong was the urge, from one to ten?
- Test it. What is the evidence for and against the thought? What is it leaving out?
- Sort it. What part of this is in your control, and what is not?
- The worthy response. What would the person you want to be do next?
- Re-rate. How strong is the urge now?
The first four steps are close to a standard CBT thought record. The last three are Stoic additions: the dichotomy of control, a question about character, and a check on the result. Together they turn a worksheet into a small act of philosophy.
One thing for tonight
Try the seven-step Stoic thought record at the end of this page on one moment from today.
Questions
Is CBT based on Stoicism?
Partly. CBT has several roots, including behavioural psychology and the clinical work of Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck. Both Ellis and Beck acknowledged the Stoics as philosophical forerunners - Ellis often quoted Epictetus’s line that people are disturbed not by things but by the views they take of them. CBT itself is a modern, evidence-tested therapy, not an ancient philosophy.
Does CBT work for alcohol problems?
CBT is one of the recommended psychological treatments. In England, NICE guidance advises offering psychological interventions such as cognitive behavioural therapies for harmful drinking and mild alcohol dependence, and the NHS lists problems with alcohol among the conditions CBT can help with. Your GP can refer you, or you may be able to refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies.
Can Stoicism replace therapy?
No. Stoicism is a philosophy, not a treatment, and it has not been tested as a treatment for alcohol problems. It can sit comfortably alongside CBT, 12-step groups, SMART Recovery and medical care, and many people find it helps them keep going between sessions and after treatment ends.
What is the difference between Stoicism and CBT?
CBT is a structured, time-limited therapy aimed at specific problems, delivered by a trained therapist, with goals agreed at the start. Stoicism is a philosophy of life. It asks not only “is this thought accurate?” but “what kind of person do I want to be?”, and it offers values - wisdom, courage, justice and self-control - as well as techniques.
What is SMART Recovery’s connection to CBT?
SMART Recovery is a mutual-help programme that draws on cognitive behavioural and motivational approaches. Its tools, such as weighing up the costs and benefits of drinking, overlap with both CBT and Stoic practices.
Sources and further reading
- The Western origins of mindfulness therapy in ancient Rome Cavanna and colleagues, Neurological Sciences (2023)A review noting that Stoic philosophy has multiple parallels with cognitive behavioural therapy.
- Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) NHSLists problems with alcohol among the conditions CBT can help with; CBT is free on the NHS.
- Alcohol-use disorders (CG115): recommendations NICERecommends offering a psychological intervention, such as cognitive behavioural therapy, for harmful drinking and mild alcohol dependence.
- Relapse prevention: an overview of Marlatt’s cognitive-behavioral model Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, Alcohol Research & Health (1999)High-risk situations, coping skills, urge management and the “abstinence violation effect” after a lapse.
- The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
- The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
- Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Stoic Ethics Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Alcohol support NHSWhere to get help in the UK, including Drinkline (0300 123 1110), AA, SMART Recovery and Al-Anon.
Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.