Stoic concepts

Role ethics: remembering who you are

A craving wants you to be only one thing - a person with a thirst. Epictetus taught a way of working out what to do by remembering everything else you are - to your children, your partner, your friends, your work. It is one of the most motivating ideas in Stoicism.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Write down three roles you hold - parent, friend, colleague - and what each needs from you tomorrow morning. Do one small thing tonight for one of them.

The short version

  • Epictetus taught that “duties are universally measured by relations” - you can work out what to do by looking at who you are to people.
  • In Discourses 2.10 he lists roles one by one - a human being, a citizen of the world, a son or daughter, a brother or sister - and asks what each one “promises”.
  • Your side of a relationship does not depend on the other person behaving well. Even if a brother is unjust, Epictetus says, keep your own just relation towards him.
  • In recovery, roles bring back the reasons you started - usually people - and give you a way to act well even when you do not feel like it.
  • Roles are a source of meaning, not a stick to beat yourself with.

“Consider who you are”

Epictetus has a discourse with a long title - How we may discover the duties of life from names - that begins with three words: “Consider who you are.” Then he goes through the roles a person holds, one at a time.

First, he says, you are a human being, with the power of reason and choice. Then a citizen of the world, a part of the whole, who should act “as the hand or foot would do, if they had reason and understood the constitution of nature”. Then:

“After this, remember that you are a son. What does this character promise?”

And:

“After this know that you are a brother also, and that to this character it is due to make concessions; to be easily persuaded, to speak good of your brother…”

He continues with other roles - senator, young person, old person - and explains that each name, properly considered, tells you how to act. The question is always the same: what does this role promise? What does someone in this position owe the people around them?

“Duties are measured by relations”

In the Enchiridion, Epictetus puts the idea in one sentence:

“Duties are universally measured by relations.”

And then he gives an example that is very relevant to anyone dealing with difficult families:

“Is a brother unjust? Well, preserve your own just relation toward him. Consider not what he does, but what you are to do to keep your own faculty of choice in a state conformable to nature.”

This is a demanding idea and a freeing one. Demanding, because it means you cannot excuse your own behaviour by pointing to someone else’s. Freeing, because it means your side of every relationship is fully in your hands. You cannot control whether your father is kind, whether your partner understands, whether your friend lets you down. You can always control whether you keep your side.

Why roles matter in recovery

A craving narrows who you are

One of the strange things about a craving is how it shrinks your identity. In the moment, you are not a parent, a sister, a friend, a colleague, a person with plans. You are just someone who wants a drink. All the other roles fade.

Epictetus’s exercise reverses that. Asking “who am I to the people in my life?” brings everything else back into view. The person at the kitchen table at 9pm with a craving is also the parent who will be making breakfast at 7, the friend who promised to help on Saturday, the colleague with a meeting at 10.

People are usually the reason

Ask people in recovery why they stopped, and the answers are very often about people. Children who were frightened. A partner who was close to leaving. Friends who had stopped calling. A parent they wanted to make proud. Role ethics gives those reasons a structure. It is not about guilt. It is about remembering what you are for.

You do not have to feel like it

Roles also help when motivation is low. You may not feel like being patient, kind or sober tonight. But a parent makes breakfast whether or not they feel like it. A friend turns up. Roles carry you through when feelings do not, which is exactly what is needed on the hard evenings.

The trap to avoid: roles as guilt

There is a misuse of this idea that can do real harm. If you use your roles only to remind yourself how badly you have failed in them - “I’m a terrible parent, a useless partner” - they become another source of shame. And shame, as many people in recovery know, is one of the most reliable ways back to drinking.

Epictetus was not interested in punishing anyone. His question was forward-looking: what does this role ask of you now? You may have fallen short as a parent while drinking. The role still asks the same thing of you today, and today is where you can meet it. That is what Steps 8 and 9 of the 12 Steps are partly about: recognising harm done in our relationships and repairing what we can. (Step 8 and Stoicism.)

How to practise it

The three-role check

When an urge arrives, write down three roles you hold. Beside each, write one line: what does this role need from me tomorrow morning? Then do one small thing tonight that the person in that role would do. Text the friend. Lay out the school uniforms. Prepare for the meeting.

The morning roles

Marcus Aurelius began his days by reminding himself of the work he was made for. Try starting the day with your roles: “Today I am a parent, a partner, a colleague, a friend. What does each of these need from me?” It takes a minute and frames the day.

When someone else behaves badly

When a family member or colleague provokes you - especially if the provocation pulls you towards a drink - use Epictetus’s question, in your own words: “Not what he does, but what I am to do.” Write down the role you hold towards them, and what keeping your side of it would look like tonight. Often the answer is simply: not to drink on it, and not to escalate.

New roles in recovery

Recovery often adds new roles: someone in a group, a sponsor, a person who helps others. Epictetus thought of humans as citizens of the world with responsibilities to people beyond their immediate circle. The twelfth step - carrying the message to others - is a role in exactly this sense. (Oikeiosis - widening the circle.)

The actor and the part

Epictetus also offered a famous image that sits alongside role ethics:

“Remember that you are an actor in a drama of such sort as the Author chooses - if short, then in a short one; if long, then in a long one… For this is your business - to act well the given part, but to choose it belongs to another.”

You did not choose every circumstance of your life - your family, your history, perhaps your vulnerability to alcohol. Those are, in Epictetus’s image, the part you were given. Your business is to play it well. A person in recovery playing their part well - honestly, patiently, sober - is doing exactly what Epictetus asked.

Role ethics is one expression of the wider Stoic belief that humans are made to live together, which the Stoics called oikeiosis. It also connects with the four virtues, especially justice, which for the Stoics covered how we treat other people.

The Insight Tool uses “Your roles” as one of its Stoic angles, particularly for parenting stress, family difficulties and arguments with people close to you.

One thing for tonight

Before bed, name one person who is relying on you tomorrow, and what you want them to see.

Questions

What is role ethics in Stoicism?

It is the idea, developed especially by Epictetus, that our appropriate actions can be worked out from our roles and relationships - as a human being, a family member, a friend, a citizen, in our work. Each role carries its own responsibilities.

What if the other person in the relationship behaves badly?

Epictetus’s answer is that your duty depends on the relationship, not on their behaviour. In the Enchiridion he says that even if a brother is unjust, you should “preserve your own just relation toward him” and consider “not what he does, but what you are to do”.

How does this help me stay sober?

When an urge arrives, asking “who am I to the people in my life, and what does that role ask of me tonight?” brings your values back into view. It turns sobriety from a rule into a way of being the parent, partner or friend you want to be.

Sources and further reading

  1. A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
  2. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  3. Epictetus Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  4. Epictetus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  5. Stoic Ethics Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.