Justice as Virtue
The Step “Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.” For the Stoics, justice was not primarily about law. It was about giving each person what they are owed.
Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone
If you only do one thing
Write down one person your drinking affected, and one honest sentence about how. No more than that, today.
The short version
- Step 8 is making a list of people harmed by your drinking and becoming willing to make amends.
- Willingness comes first. You do not have to know how you will make every amends yet.
- Marcus Aurelius reminded himself that “you also do many things wrong” - a cure for both self-righteousness and despair.
- Epictetus taught that our duties follow from our relationships. The list is really a map of who you are to other people.
Of the four Stoic cardinal virtues, justice is the one most explicitly directed outward. Wisdom, courage, and temperance primarily concern your relationship with yourself. Justice concerns your relationship with other people and with the world.
Stoic justice was not about punishment or law. It was about giving to each thing what it is owed. To a friend, honest engagement. To an enemy, fair treatment. To someone you have wronged, acknowledgement and repair where possible. The Stoics saw justice as the natural expression of recognising the full humanity of everyone you encounter.
Marcus Aurelius wrote about this frequently in the context of how to treat people who had wronged him. His test was not how they had behaved, but what a just person would do. Justice was internal. Your standard of conduct did not depend on whether the other person deserved it.
“If it is not right, do not do it; if it is not true, do not say it.”
The parallel to Step 8
Making a list of people you have harmed is an act of justice in the Stoic sense. It is taking the reality of what has happened seriously. It is acknowledging that the harm existed, that the other person is real, and that something is owed.
The second part, becoming willing, is where the Stoic understanding of virtue becomes practical. The willingness does not have to come first. You do not have to feel willing before you can become willing. The Stoics understood that action precedes feeling as often as it follows it. You build willingness the way you build any other capacity: by practising it.
Notice the step does not say make amends yet. It says become willing. The list is the honest accounting. The willingness is the orientation. Both require courage. Neither requires perfection.
What this Step can feel like
Writing down the people you have harmed can be painful. It brings faces and moments into focus. It can also stir up resentment - many people on the list have hurt you too.
Step 8 asks only for a list and willingness. You do not yet have to know how you will make every amends, or whether some should be made at all.
A Stoic way into Step 8
Marcus Aurelius kept a list of remedies for anger at other people. One of them is useful here:
“consider that you also do many things wrong, and that you are a man like others”
That line cuts two ways. It undercuts the self-righteousness that says “they hurt me more”. And it undercuts the despair that says “I am uniquely bad”. You are a person like others, who has done harm, as people do. That is the starting point for making things right.
Epictetus taught that our duties follow from our relationships - parent, partner, friend, colleague. The Step 8 list is really a map of those relationships, and of where your side of them was broken. Willingness means being prepared to keep your side again. (Role ethics.)
- Write the names. Everyone your drinking affected, without deciding yet what to do.
- Next to each, one plain sentence about what happened, from your side only.
- Notice resistance. Who do you not want to put on the list? Ask why.
- Add yourself. Many people find they harmed themselves most of all.
Write the list. Be thorough rather than dramatic. For each person, note briefly what the harm was and, if you can, what was driving you at the time. Not to excuse it, but to understand it. Understanding the pattern is part of not repeating it.
Journaling question: Who have I been avoiding accounting for, and what does the avoidance cost me as well as them?
The book maps the same territory - one month per Step, 365 daily entries pairing a Stoic principle with the work of each step. Can be started on any day of the year. Ataraxia: A Year of Stoic Recovery.
August: justice
A short daily reading for every day of August, running alongside Step 8: a Stoic passage, a note and one action. Free on this site.
Read August’s reflectionsOne thing for tonight
Ask yourself - who am I to this person, and what would keeping my side of that relationship look like now?
Questions
Who should go on my Step 8 list?
Many people include anyone harmed by their drinking or behaviour - family, friends, colleagues, sometimes themselves. A sponsor can help you think it through.
What if someone harmed me too?
That is common. Step 8 focuses on your side of the relationship, not theirs. Epictetus advised keeping your own just relation towards others, whatever they do - which does not mean accepting ongoing harm.
Sources and further reading
- Alcoholics Anonymous AA World Services
- Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder Kelly, Humphreys and Ferri, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)The major review of the evidence on AA and 12-step facilitation.
- The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
- Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
The Twelve Steps are those of Alcoholics Anonymous; this page offers a Stoic reading alongside them. Not medical advice - if you drink heavily every day, speak to your GP before stopping.