Step 9 of 12

Virtuous Action

The Step “Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.” The Stoics had no patience for virtue that stayed theoretical. Action was the test of everything.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Choose the simplest amends on your list - one that will not cause harm - and decide what you will say or do, and when.

The short version

  • Step 9 is making direct amends wherever possible - except when doing so would cause harm.
  • Amends are more than apologies. They are changed behaviour, and sometimes practical repair.
  • Epictetus advised keeping your own just relation towards others, whatever they do.
  • Some amends cannot be made directly. Living differently is an amends too.

For the Stoics, virtue was not an internal state or a belief system. It was a pattern of action. Marcus Aurelius told himself: “No longer talk at all about the kind of man that a good man ought to be, but be such” (Meditations 10.16). The measure of character was not what you intended or believed but what you actually did.

This is both demanding and clarifying. It cuts through the gap between self-concept and behaviour that addiction often widens. You may have a strong self-image as someone who is honest, loyal, and decent. The inventory has shown you places where your actions did not match that image. Step 9 is where the gap begins to close.

The Stoics held that virtue in action is the only true good. Not virtue planned. Not virtue felt. Virtue expressed in the specific choices you make with specific people in specific moments.

“Is a brother unjust? Well, preserve your own just relation toward him. Consider not what he does, but what you are to do”
Epictetus, Enchiridion 30

The parallel to Step 9

The qualification, except when to do so would injure them or others, is a piece of genuine Stoic practical wisdom. The goal is not to discharge your guilt. The goal is to repair harm where repair is possible and helpful. These are not always the same thing. An amend that reopens wounds or causes new harm is not an amend. It is a burden transferred.

The Stoics would say: discern carefully. Act wisely. The intention to repair is not enough. The action has to actually serve the person you harmed, not just relieve your own conscience.

What this step requires is courage. Not the dramatic courage of grand gestures, but the quiet courage of sitting with someone you have hurt and saying, honestly and without defence, what you did and what you are doing about it. That is a small action. It is also very difficult. And it is, in the Stoic sense, virtuous: it costs something real and serves something real.

What this Step can feel like

Step 9 is where recovery becomes visible to other people. That can feel exposing and uncertain. You cannot control how anyone will respond. Some people will welcome your amends; some will not; some may not be reachable.

A Stoic way into Step 9

This is where the Stoic distinction between what is and is not in your control becomes very practical. How the other person responds is not in your control. Whether you make an honest, appropriate amends is.

Epictetus put it in terms of relationships:

“Is a brother unjust? Well, preserve your own just relation toward him. Consider not what he does, but what you are to do”
Epictetus, Enchiridion 30

Your amends is your side of the relationship. It does not depend on their forgiveness, and it is not a bargain. You do it because it is right, and then you let the outcome be theirs. (The reserve clause.)

Marcus Aurelius left himself a blunt reminder that applies here: “No longer talk at all about the kind of man that a good man ought to be, but be such.” Amends are not just words about the person you want to be. They are the person you want to be, acting.

Practising Step 9
  1. Start with the simplest amends - one that is clear, safe and within reach.
  2. Plan what you will say. Short, specific, without excuses or expectations.
  3. Check for harm. If an amends could hurt them or others, talk it through with a sponsor first.
  4. Make living amends. Where direct amends are not possible, change how you live.
  5. Let go of the response. Your part is the amends. Their reaction is theirs.

Practical reflection

For each person on your list, ask: what would genuine repair look like for them, not for me? In some cases it will be a conversation. In some cases it will be changed behaviour over time. In some cases it will be leaving someone alone to heal. For each, identify the next right action, however small.

Journaling question: Where am I confusing the desire to feel forgiven with the actual work of making things right?

The book maps the same territory - one month per Step, 365 daily entries pairing a Stoic principle with the work of each step. Can be started on any day of the year. Ataraxia: A Year of Stoic Recovery.

September: courage in repair

A short daily reading for every day of September, running alongside Step 9: a Stoic passage, a note and one action. Free on this site.

Read September’s reflections

One thing for tonight

If an amends is not possible, write what you would say, then decide how you will live differently instead.

Questions

What is the difference between an apology and an amends?

An apology says sorry. An amends tries to put things right - acknowledging the harm, repairing what can be repaired, and changing the behaviour that caused it.

What if making amends would hurt someone?

The Step itself says not to make amends when doing so would injure them or others. In those cases, many people make “living amends” - changing how they live - and talk it through with a sponsor or counsellor.

Sources and further reading

  1. Alcoholics Anonymous AA World Services
  2. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder Kelly, Humphreys and Ferri, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2020)The major review of the evidence on AA and 12-step facilitation.
  3. Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource
  4. Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

The Twelve Steps are those of Alcoholics Anonymous; this page offers a Stoic reading alongside them. Not medical advice - if you drink heavily every day, speak to your GP before stopping.