Premeditatio malorum: rehearsing the hard moment
Most relapses do not happen in a calm hour. They happen at the wedding, after the phone call, at 6pm on a Friday. The Stoics had a practice for meeting those moments with a plan made in advance - and it is one of the most practical tools they left.
Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone
If you only do one thing
Name the next moment likely to test you, and write exactly what you will say, what you will drink instead, and when you will leave.
The short version
- Premeditatio malorum means “the premeditation of evils” - deliberately imagining difficulties before they happen.
- Seneca wrote that “nothing ought to be unexpected by us”, and that the unexpected weighs most heavily. Epictetus advised picturing what usually happens before you set out to do anything.
- It is not pessimism. The point is to make decisions in a calm hour, so that in the hard moment you are following a plan rather than improvising under pressure.
- In recovery, this is close to the high-risk-situation planning at the heart of modern relapse prevention.
- {’A good plan is specific’: ‘the moment, what you will say, what you will drink instead, and how you will leave.’}
What the Stoics said
Seneca: send the mind ahead
Seneca returned to this idea many times. In Letter 91, written after a fire destroyed the city of Lyon, he explains why the unexpected hurts most:
”…for it is the unexpected that puts the heaviest load upon us. Strangeness adds to the weight of calamities, and every mortal feels the greater pain as a result of that which also brings surprise. Therefore, nothing ought to be unexpected by us. Our minds should be sent forward in advance to meet all problems, and we should consider, not what is wont to happen, but what can happen.”
In Letter 24, writing to a friend frightened about a lawsuit, he gives a sharper version. Do not run from the worst case, he says. Walk towards it:
”…if you would put off all worry, assume that what you fear may happen will certainly happen in any event; whatever the trouble may be, measure it in your own mind, and estimate the amount of your fear. You will thus understand that what you fear is either insignificant or short-lived.”
Epictetus: picture the bathhouse
Epictetus gives the most everyday example. Before you go to the public baths, he says, picture what happens there:
“If you are going to bathe, represent to yourself the incidents usual in the bath - some persons pouring out, others pushing in, others scolding, others pilfering.”
Then, he says, set your intention: “I will now go to bathe and keep my own will in harmony with nature.” That way, when someone splashes you or steals your towel, you are not knocked off course. You knew it might happen, and you went anyway with your purpose clear.
Swap the bathhouse for a wedding reception or a Christmas lunch, and the advice is exactly the same.
Marcus: expect difficult people
Marcus Aurelius began his day by expecting trouble:
“Begin the morning by saying to yourself, I shall meet with the busy-body, the ungrateful, arrogant, deceitful, envious, unsocial.”
He was not being cynical. He goes on to say that such people act out of ignorance, that he cannot be harmed by them, and that we are made to work together. The point of expecting them was so that they would not catch him off guard and pull him into anger.
Why it works
The logic is simple, and modern psychology broadly agrees with it.
Decisions are better made calm. In the middle of a craving, the mind is not at its best. Under stress, tiredness or strong emotion, people tend to act on habit rather than reflection. A plan made in advance does the thinking for you when you are least able to do it.
Surprise is destabilising. When something unexpected happens - someone presses a drink into your hand, an old friend suggests “just one” - there is a moment of confusion where the familiar response takes over. Rehearsal removes the surprise. You have already been there in imagination.
Fear shrinks when measured. Much of the dread before a difficult event is vague: “it will be awful”. Seneca’s method makes it specific. Once you have pictured exactly what might happen, it usually turns out to be manageable.
This is very close to the approach of relapse prevention, the model developed by the psychologist Alan Marlatt and colleagues, which treats high-risk situations - particular emotions, people, places and social pressures - as the main moments of danger, and helps people plan coping responses for them in advance.
How to rehearse a hard moment
Here is a practical method, combining Seneca, Epictetus and modern relapse prevention. You can do it in ten minutes with a pen and paper, or use the urge plan worksheet.
1. Pick the moment
Be specific. Not “social events” but “Sarah’s wedding on Saturday, especially the drinks reception and the speeches”. Not “stress” but “Thursday evenings after the weekly meeting with my manager”.
2. Picture it as it will really be
Like Epictetus at the bathhouse, picture the usual incidents. Who will be there? What will they be drinking? Who is likely to offer you a drink, and what will they say? At what point in the event will the urge be strongest? What will you be feeling?
Do not make it worse than it is likely to be, and do not make it better. Aim for accuracy.
3. Measure the fear
Following Seneca, ask: what is the worst that could realistically happen? Someone thinks you are boring? Someone asks why you are not drinking? You feel awkward for twenty minutes? Write it down. Then ask whether you could live with it. Usually the answer is yes.
4. Decide your responses
Write down exactly:
- What you will say when offered a drink. Keep it short and do not explain: “I’m fine with this, thanks.”
- What you will drink instead, and how you will get it early so your hand is never empty.
- Who you can contact - someone who knows your plan and will answer a text.
- When you will leave - a time, not “when it gets too much”.
- Your exit line - “I’ve got an early start.”
5. Set your purpose
Epictetus’s sentence before the bath was not only about avoiding trouble. It set his purpose: to keep his will in harmony with nature. Write one line for yourself: “I’m going to this wedding to celebrate my friend and come home sober.”
6. Rehearse once
Say your lines out loud, once. It feels silly. It also makes them much easier to say when the moment comes.
7. Review afterwards
After the event, look back. What happened that you expected? What surprised you? What would you do differently next time? This is Seneca’s evening review applied to a single event, and it makes the next plan better.
Common moments to plan for
- Being offered a drink - at work, at parties, by family.
- Celebrations - weddings, birthdays, Christmas, leaving dos.
- The end of the working day, especially Friday.
- Arguments and difficult phone calls.
- Being alone in the evening.
- Travel - airports, trains, hotel rooms.
- Payday.
- Anniversaries of losses or difficult events.
- Good news, when celebrating “just this once” feels harmless.
The Insight Tool has entries for most of these, and its Stoic angle “Rehearse it in advance” will walk you through a short version of this exercise.
When premeditatio goes wrong
Like any tool, this can be misused.
- If it turns into rumination, stop. The exercise should end with a plan, not with you replaying the fear over and over. Keep it to ten minutes.
- If you find yourself rehearsing drinking, notice it. Imagining the drink in detail can turn into a craving. Focus on your responses, not on the alcohol.
- If the anxiety is constant, it may be more than ordinary worry. Talk to your GP; anxiety is common and treatable.
The reserve clause: plans that can bend
Seneca paired forward planning with another idea: hold your plans with a condition attached. “I will set sail unless anything happens to prevent me.” You plan carefully, and you accept that things may not go to plan. If the wedding runs late, if your friend lets you down, if the party is harder than you expected, your purpose still stands even if the details change. We cover this in the reserve clause.
Rehearsal and flexibility together are the Stoic formula: expect difficulty, prepare for it, and do not be thrown when it arrives in a different shape from the one you imagined.
One thing for tonight
Say your words for that moment out loud once. It feels silly and it works.
Questions
What does premeditatio malorum mean?
It is Latin for “the premeditation of evils” or “thinking ahead about troubles”. It describes the Stoic practice of imagining difficulties in advance, so that you are prepared for them and less shaken when they happen.
Isn’t imagining bad things just anxiety?
Not when it is done well. Anxiety replays a fear without resolving it. Premeditatio walks up to the difficulty, sizes it and ends with a plan. Seneca’s advice was to measure the fear calmly, and he found it was usually “either insignificant or short-lived”. If the exercise leaves you more anxious, shorten it and focus on the plan rather than the fear.
How is this used in recovery?
By identifying the situations most likely to lead to drinking - certain people, places, feelings and times - and deciding in advance exactly what you will do in each. This is also a central part of modern relapse prevention.
Sources and further reading
- Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard Mott Gummere Wikisource
- The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
- The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
- Relapse prevention: an overview of Marlatt’s cognitive-behavioral model Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, Alcohol Research & Health (1999)High-risk situations, coping skills, urge management and the “abstinence violation effect” after a lapse.
- Seneca Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Stoic Ethics Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.