Stoic concepts

Testing impressions: the Stoic thought check

A craving does not arrive as a feeling. It arrives as a sentence that sounds like a fact - “I need a drink”, “I deserve this”, “one won’t hurt”. The Stoics built their whole psychology around the moment between that sentence and your agreement with it.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Write the urge as one exact sentence in quotation marks. Ask what it claims, what you actually know, and what it leaves out. Then decline to agree.

The short version

  • The Stoics called the thoughts and appearances that present themselves to us “impressions”. Their claim was that impressions happen to us, but agreeing with them - assent - is up to us.
  • Epictetus told his students to say to every harsh impression, “You are an appearance, and in no manner what you appear to be”, and then examine it.
  • In recovery, the most important impressions are the sentences a craving uses - “I need a drink”, “I’ve earned it”, “just one won’t hurt”.
  • Testing means slowing down, naming the impression exactly, checking it against what you know, and deciding whether to agree.
  • This overlaps closely with the thought-challenging used in cognitive behavioural therapy.

What the Stoics meant by an impression

The Stoics had a precise account of how the mind works. Things appear to us - through the senses, through memory, through thoughts that simply arise. They called each of these an impression. An impression is not yet a belief. It is a proposal: this is so.

Then comes the decisive step, which they called assent. You either agree with the impression or you do not. If you see a stick in water and it looks bent, the impression says “the stick is bent”. You can assent to that, or you can recognise it as a trick of the light and withhold agreement.

For the Stoics, almost everything important happened at that step. Emotions, in their view, are not things that just happen to us. They follow from judgements we have agreed to - that something is terrible, that we must have something, that we have been wronged. Change the judgement and the emotion changes with it.

That is why Epictetus could say:

“Men are disturbed not by things, but by the views which they take of things.”

And it is why Marcus Aurelius could write, of his own anger:

“Take away your opinion, and then there is taken away the complaint, ‘I have been harmed.’ Take away the complaint, ‘I have been harmed,’ and the harm is taken away.”

You do not have to accept the whole of Stoic psychology to find this useful. The practical point is simple: there is a moment between a thought arriving and you acting on it, and that moment can be widened.

Epictetus at the door

Epictetus, who taught in the early second century, made testing impressions the centre of his training. The first chapter of the Enchiridion ends with an instruction:

“Straightway then practise saying to every harsh appearance, You are an appearance, and in no manner what you appear to be. Then examine it by the rules which you possess, and by this first and chiefly, whether it relates to the things which are in our power or to things which are not in our power”

In the Discourses he gives a more vivid version, written specifically about the impressions of pleasure and desire:

“But in the first place, be not hurried away by the rapidity of the appearance, but say, Appearances, wait for me a little; let me see who you are, and what you are about; let me put you to the test.”

Imagine a doorman at a club, checking each person before letting them in. The impression knocks. It looks confident, well dressed, sure of its welcome. The doorman says: wait. Let me see your papers.

Epictetus goes on to describe what happens if you do not stop at the door:

“This is the true athlete, the man who exercises himself against such appearances. Stay, wretch, do not be carried away. Great is the combat, divine is the work; it is for kingship, for freedom, for happiness, for freedom from perturbation.”

It is striking that he uses the language of athletics. For Epictetus, this was training. You get better at it with practice, and every impression tested is a repetition.

The impressions a craving uses

A craving is partly physical - a restlessness, a pull, a tight chest - but it nearly always speaks. And what it says is designed to be agreed with. Here are some of the most common impressions in recovery:

  • “I need a drink.” Presents a want as a need.
  • “I can’t get through tonight without one.” A prediction, stated as a certainty.
  • “I deserve it.” Mixes a true claim (you deserve something good) with a false one (the good thing is a drink).
  • “Just one won’t hurt.” May be true for some people. The question is whether it has been true for you.
  • “I’ve already blown it.” After a slip, the impression that one drink means total failure. Relapse researchers call this the abstinence violation effect.
  • “My drinking wasn’t that bad.” Memory softens over time. The impression uses the softened version.
  • “Everyone else is drinking.” Possibly accurate, and irrelevant to what drinking does to you.
  • “Nobody would know.” Leaves out the one person who would.

Notice that each one sounds reasonable on first hearing. That is the point. An impression that sounded absurd would be easy to reject. The ones that cause trouble are the ones that sound like common sense.

How to test an impression: a step-by-step method

The Stoics did not leave a worksheet, but their writing contains the steps. Here is a practical version.

1. Slow down

Epictetus’s first instruction was not to be “hurried away by the rapidity of the appearance”. Cravings rely on urgency. The single most useful thing you can do is refuse the deadline: nothing gets decided in the next twenty minutes. The Urge Timer is designed for exactly this.

2. Name the impression exactly

Write it down, in quotation marks, as if someone else said it. “I can’t cope tonight without a drink.” Putting it in quotation marks does something important: it turns the thought from your voice into a statement you can look at.

3. Strip it plainly

Marcus Aurelius trained himself to see things without their glamour. Famous wine was “only a little grape-juice”; a purple robe was “some sheep’s wool dyed with the blood of a shell-fish”. Do the same with the impression. What is it actually offering? Usually: a liquid that will change how you feel for an hour or two, and then take your sleep and your morning.

4. Check it against what you know

Ask:

  • What does this impression claim?
  • What do I actually know to be true?
  • What does it leave out - especially about later tonight and tomorrow?
  • Has this impression been right before? What happened last time I believed it?

5. Sort it

Epictetus said the first and chief test is whether the impression concerns things in your power or not. The urge arriving is not in your power. Whether you drink is. “I feel terrible” may be true and outside your control right now. “So I have to drink” is a separate claim, and it is about something you control.

6. Decide whether to agree

You do not have to win an argument with the craving or make it go away. You only have to decline to agree with it. “That is an impression. I’m not assenting to it.” Then do something else with your hands.

Why this is not just positive thinking

Testing impressions is sometimes confused with telling yourself nice things. It is the opposite. The Stoics were trying to see more accurately, not more comfortably.

Sometimes testing an impression shows that it is true. “This is going to be a hard evening” may be entirely accurate. The test does not make it false. It separates it from the extra claim attached to it - “and therefore I must drink” - which is where the damage happens.

This is also why the method works better than willpower alone. Willpower tries to overpower the craving. Testing changes your relationship to it. You stop treating the craving’s statements as facts you have to fight and start treating them as claims you can examine.

The connection with modern therapy

The founders of cognitive therapy - Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck - both acknowledged the Stoics as philosophical forerunners, and CBT’s practice of catching and examining automatic thoughts is a close relative of testing impressions. Relapse prevention, the approach developed by Alan Marlatt and colleagues, also teaches people to challenge the expectations and thoughts that lead towards a drink and to manage the “abstinence violation effect” after a slip.

The Stoic version adds something these approaches do not always emphasise: the idea that this is a lifelong training, practised on small things every day so that it is ready for the big ones. Epictetus suggested starting with trivial impressions - a spilt drink, a lost item - so that the habit is strong when it matters. (More on how Stoicism and CBT connect.)

Practising on small things

You do not need to wait for a craving to practise. Try testing impressions on ordinary irritations:

  • Someone cuts in front of you in traffic. Impression: “What an idiot, this has ruined my morning.” Test: what do I actually know? What part of my morning is still mine?
  • A message goes unanswered. Impression: “They’re ignoring me.” Test: what else might be true?
  • You make a mistake at work. Impression: “I’m useless.” Test: is one mistake evidence of uselessness?

Each test is a repetition. When the bigger impression comes - “I need a drink” - the habit of stopping at the door is already in place.

Using the Insight Tool to test impressions

The Insight Tool on this site has a questions mode built on this method. Choose what is happening, press “Ask me questions instead”, and it will take you through three questions for one Stoic angle, then read your own answers back to you. Nothing you type leaves your device.

You can also print the control worksheet and use it as a paper version: write the impression at the top, then sort it into what is and is not in your control.

A note on what this cannot do

Testing impressions is a thinking skill. It is very useful, and it is not enough on its own for everyone. If your drinking is heavy, if you are dependent, or if you have tried and failed to stop many times, combine it with support - a group, therapy or medical help. If you drink heavily every day, speak to a doctor before stopping, because withdrawal can be dangerous. The Stoics would have approved. Marcus Aurelius - who first read Epictetus’s discourses thanks to his teacher Rusticus, and who became the most powerful man in the world - reminded himself: “Be not ashamed to be helped.”

One thing for tonight

Practise on something small - an irritating message, a delay - and catch the first thought before you believe it.

Questions

What is an impression in Stoicism?

An impression (in Greek, phantasia) is the way something appears to the mind - a perception, a thought or a judgement as it first presents itself. The Stoics thought impressions arrive automatically, but that we can examine them before agreeing (assenting) to them.

What is the discipline of assent?

It is the modern name, used especially in discussions of Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius, for the practice of examining impressions before accepting them. The idea is that freedom lies in the gap between how something appears and whether you agree with it.

How does this help with cravings?

A craving comes with thoughts that sound true - “I can’t cope without a drink tonight”. Testing them shows how much they claim and how little they know. You do not have to win an argument with the craving. You only have to decline to agree with it.

Is this the same as CBT?

It is closely related. Cognitive behavioural therapy also teaches people to catch automatic thoughts and examine the evidence for them, and its founders acknowledged the Stoics as forerunners. See our page on Stoicism and CBT.

Sources and further reading

  1. A Selection from the Discourses of Epictetus with the Encheiridion, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 10661
  2. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109
  3. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  4. Stoicism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  5. Epictetus Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  6. Epictetus Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  7. Relapse prevention: an overview of Marlatt’s cognitive-behavioral model Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, Alcohol Research & Health (1999)High-risk situations, coping skills, urge management and the “abstinence violation effect” after a lapse.

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.