Understanding your drinking

Cutting down or quitting?

Most people who worry about their drinking would rather cut down than stop. That is understandable, and for some people it works. For others, it becomes years of rules made and broken. The useful question is not which sounds better, but which is honestly likely to work for you.

Struggling right now? Urge Timer Insight Tool Talk to someone

If you only do one thing

Write down every rule you have ever made about drinking - “only at weekends”, “never before six”, “just two” - and next to each, honestly, how long it lasted.

The short version

  • UK clinical guidance (NICE) says abstinence is the appropriate goal for most people with alcohol dependence, and for people with significant mental or physical health problems linked to drinking.
  • For harmful drinking or mild dependence without those complications, NICE says a goal of moderation may be considered.
  • Your own track record is the best evidence. If limits keep breaking, that tells you more than your intentions do.
  • Moderation needs specific rules, honest tracking and a time limit for the experiment.
  • Marcus Aurelius noted that many people “cannot enjoy without excess” certain pleasures. For them, abstaining is not the weaker option - it is the free one.

“I don’t want to stop completely. I just want to drink less.” It is one of the most common things people say when they first admit their drinking worries them. Stopping completely can sound extreme, permanent and frightening. Cutting down sounds reasonable.

For some people, it is. For others, “cutting down” becomes a long series of rules that keep breaking. This page is about telling the difference honestly - using clinical guidance, your own history, and a little Stoic clarity.

Pause here for a moment. Breathe in as the circle grows and out as it shrinks. Three slow breaths is enough. The rest of the page will wait.

What the guidance says

In England, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) publishes clinical guidance on alcohol problems. On treatment goals, it says:

  • Abstinence is the appropriate goal for most people with alcohol dependence, and for people who misuse alcohol and have significant psychiatric or physical health problems (for example, depression or alcohol-related liver disease).
  • For harmful drinking or mild dependence, without significant health complications and with adequate support, a goal of moderation may be considered.

NICE also says that where someone prefers moderation but there are considerable risks, they should be strongly advised that abstinence is most appropriate - but should not be refused help if they disagree.

In other words: moderation is a reasonable goal for some people, particularly earlier on. For people who are dependent, or whose drinking is already harming their health, stopping is generally the safer approach.

Your own track record

Guidance describes groups of people. You are one person, with your own history. And your history is probably the best evidence you have.

Ask yourself honestly:

  • How many times have I set a limit on my drinking?
  • How long did each one last?
  • When I break a limit, do I tend to drink a little over, or a lot?
  • Do I spend a lot of energy managing, negotiating and justifying my drinking?
  • When I have one drink, how often does it stay at one?

If you have set limits and kept them, that is encouraging. If you have a long history of rules made and broken - weekdays only, never before six, just two - that pattern is telling you something important.

Remember

Intentions are not evidence. What has actually happened, over and over, is evidence. Be as honest with your own record as you would be with a friend’s.

The hidden cost of moderation

Moderation can look easier than stopping. Often it is harder.

When you stop, you make one decision. When you moderate, you make a decision every evening: whether to drink, how much, whether today counts as an exception. Each of those decisions is made with alcohol’s pull on one side, and sometimes with alcohol already in your system - which is not when judgement is at its best.

Many people who have tried both describe stopping as a relief, precisely because it ended the constant negotiation. That is not true for everyone. But it is worth knowing that moderation is not automatically the gentler option.

What the Stoics said

The Stoics were not teetotallers. Seneca even recommended occasional festive drinking to refresh the mind - but he attached a condition:

“…however, we ought not to do it often, for fear the mind should contract evil habits”
Seneca, On Tranquillity of Mind 17

His permission was for occasional drinking by someone who could stop. Once the habit has formed, his own warning applies.

Marcus Aurelius put it even more clearly. Describing his adoptive father, he used a line remembered about Socrates:

“…he was able both to abstain from, and to enjoy, those things which many are too weak to abstain from, and cannot enjoy without excess.”
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 1.16

The ideal is to be able to take a pleasure or leave it. But Marcus is honest that “many” cannot enjoy certain pleasures without excess. If that describes you and alcohol, then abstaining is not a lesser version of the Stoic ideal. It is the ideal applied honestly to your situation - the way you get your freedom back. (What the Stoics said about wine.)

If you want to try cutting down

If your drinking is not dependent and you want to try moderation, do it properly - as an experiment with clear rules, not a vague intention.

A proper moderation experiment
  1. Set specific rules. For example: no more than a certain number of units a week, spread over a few days, with at least three drink-free days. The NHS advises no more than 14 units a week on a regular basis.
  2. Write them down. Before you start, not in the moment.
  3. Track every drink honestly. What, how much, when. The NHS and NIAAA’s Rethinking Drinking both offer tools.
  4. Plan your risky situations. What will you do at the party, after the hard day, on Friday?
  5. Set a time limit. One month is a good length. Long enough to learn, short enough to stay honest.
  6. Review at the end. Did you keep the rules? How hard was it? Did you keep finding exceptions? What did you notice about your sleep, mood and energy?

If the experiment goes well and stays easy, that is good news. If it was a constant struggle, or the rules kept bending, that is equally useful information - and it may point towards stopping.

If you want to stop

If you decide to stop - or your track record suggests you should - a few things help:

  • Check it is safe. If you drink heavily every day, or feel shaky, sweaty or anxious without alcohol, speak to your GP before stopping. Withdrawal can be dangerous.
  • Plan the first week. (The first week without alcohol.)
  • Think in days, not forever. “I’m not drinking today” is easier to keep than “never again”. (One day at a time.)
  • Get support. AA, SMART Recovery, your GP or a local alcohol service.

Deciding

The honest record

Write a list of every drinking rule you have made in the past few years. Next to each, write how long it lasted and how it ended. Read the list back as if it belonged to a friend. What would you advise them? That advice is usually the right answer for you too.

You do not have to decide forever today. You can decide on an experiment - a month of moderation with strict rules, or a month off - and learn from it. What matters is that the decision is made from clarity, not from avoiding a harder question.

The Stoics would ask one simple thing: are you choosing, or is the habit choosing for you? Whichever path you take, aim for the one where you are the one in charge.

If you want to talk it through, your GP or a local alcohol service can help you decide what goal is right for you. In the UK, Drinkline is free on 0300 123 1110.

One thing for tonight

Decide which experiment you will try first - a clear limit for one month, or a month off - and write down the start date and how you will track it.

Questions

Is it better to cut down or quit drinking?

It depends on your situation. NICE guidance says abstinence is the appropriate goal for most people with alcohol dependence and for those with significant related health problems, while moderation may be considered for harmful drinking or mild dependence without complications. Your own history of keeping or breaking limits is also important evidence.

Can a heavy drinker go back to moderate drinking?

Some people with less severe problems do manage to cut down successfully. For people with significant dependence, clinical guidance generally recommends abstinence, because moderation tends to be much harder to sustain. If you are unsure, talk to your GP or an alcohol service.

How do I know if I can drink in moderation?

Try it properly - set a specific limit, track every drink honestly for a month, and review. If you keep the limit easily, that is encouraging. If you keep finding exceptions, or the limit takes constant effort, stopping is likely to be easier.

Is it safe to stop drinking completely?

For most people, yes. But if you are dependent on alcohol, stopping suddenly can be dangerous. If you drink heavily every day, or get shaky, sweaty or anxious without a drink, speak to your GP before stopping.

Sources and further reading

  1. Alcohol-use disorders (CG115): recommendations NICERecommends offering a psychological intervention, such as cognitive behavioural therapy, for harmful drinking and mild alcohol dependence.
  2. Tips on cutting down on alcohol NHS
  3. Rethinking Drinking NIAAATools for checking your drinking pattern and planning to cut down or stop.
  4. Alcohol-use disorder NHSSigns of dependence, withdrawal symptoms, and why stopping suddenly can be dangerous if you are dependent.
  5. The risks of drinking too much NHSThe UK low-risk guideline of no more than 14 units a week, and the health risks of regular heavy drinking.
  6. The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, translated by George Long Project Gutenberg eBook 15877
  7. Seneca’s Minor Dialogues (including On Anger and On the Shortness of Life), translated by Aubrey Stewart Project Gutenberg eBook 64576
  8. The Enchiridion of Epictetus, translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson Project Gutenberg eBook 45109

Not medical advice. If you are drinking heavily every day, stopping suddenly can be dangerous - speak to your GP or a medical professional first.