Change of soul
You need a change of soul rather than a change of climate.Seneca, Letters 28
From Seneca’s Letter 28. His friend Lucilius had been travelling to escape low spirits and found that the gloom came with him.
Lucilius had been travelling, hoping a change of scene would lift his low mood. It did not. Seneca is not surprised. You need a change of soul, he writes, not a change of climate. You can cross the sea and leave cities behind, but your faults will follow you wherever you go, because you take yourself with you. The problem is not the place. It is the person carrying the problem from place to place.
This idea is sometimes called the geographical cure in recovery circles, and many people have tried it. A new job, a new relationship, a new city, a fresh start on Monday or in January. The hope is that different circumstances will make it easier to stop drinking. Sometimes a change of environment really does help, especially if the old one was full of triggers. But on its own, it rarely works for long. The same habits, fears and ways of coping travel with you. Within a few weeks, the new place has a new pub and the same evenings.
Seneca’s point is not that circumstances do not matter. It is that the most important change has to happen inside. A changed way of responding to stress, boredom and difficult feelings travels well. Wherever you go, you bring it with you, and it works. A changed postcode does not.
This is good news in a way, because it means you do not have to wait for your circumstances to change before you start. You do not need the new job, the house move or the end of the difficult season. You can begin the inner change where you are, today. Notice how you respond to stress. Try a different response. Notice what the urge is telling you. Try not obeying it. Each small change is a change of soul, in Seneca’s sense.
Watch today for thoughts that begin “It will be different when…” They are very common, and very persuasive. When one appears, ask a different question: what could I change about how I respond, right here, right now? That is the change that comes with you.
Try this today
Notice one “it will be different when…” thought today - when I change jobs, when the kids are older, when I move. Ask what you could change about your response right where you are.
Tonight
What am I hoping a change of circumstances will fix, that might actually need a change in me?
Reflection by Lewis Downey · quotation from Seneca in a public-domain translation
Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.