When a friend finds fault
Not to be indifferent when a friend finds fault, even if he should find fault without reason, but to try to restore him to his usual dispositionMarcus Aurelius, Meditations 1.13
From Book 1 of the Meditations. Cinna Catulus was a Stoic philosopher among Marcus’s teachers.
Marcus learned something from his teacher Catulus about how to respond to criticism from a friend. Do not be indifferent to it, even if the friend is finding fault without good reason. Instead, try to restore them to their usual good feeling. The relationship matters more than being right.
This is a demanding standard. When someone criticises us unfairly, the natural response is to defend ourselves, argue, or withdraw. Catulus asks for something different: take it seriously, and work to mend things, even if you are not at fault. That is not weakness. It is a choice to value the friendship above your pride.
In recovery, criticism from loved ones is common. Family members who were hurt by your drinking may express their anger in ways that feel unfair. They may criticise you for things that are not your fault, or bring up old grievances at difficult moments, or doubt your recovery even when you are doing well. Their criticism may be partly justified and partly not.
Humility, in Catulus’s sense, means not dismissing it. Even if some of it is unfair, it comes from somewhere - often from hurt, fear or distrust built up over years. Responding defensively usually makes things worse. Responding with patience and a desire to repair often makes things better, over time.
This does not mean accepting abuse or agreeing with everything. Some criticism is simply wrong, and you can say so calmly. But the first instinct, Catulus would suggest, should be to listen and to look for a way to restore the relationship, rather than to win the argument.
Think of a recent time someone close to you criticised you. Write down what you could do to restore the relationship, whether or not the criticism was fair. Marcus learned this from Catulus. It is one of humility’s harder lessons, and one of its most healing.
Try this today
Think of a recent time someone close to you criticised you. Whether or not it was fair, write down what you could do to restore the relationship.
Tonight
Did someone find fault with me today? How did I respond?
Reflection by Lewis Downey · quotation from Marcus Aurelius in a public-domain translation
Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.