Justice without fear

Let us withdraw ourselves in every way; for it is as harmful to be scorned as to be admired.
Seneca, Letters 14

From Seneca’s Letter 14. Seneca advises withdrawing from situations that provoke envy or contempt - both kinds of attention can harm us.

Seneca advises his friend to withdraw from situations that draw too much attention, of either kind. It is as harmful to be scorned as to be admired, he says. Both make you depend on what other people think of you. Both disturb your peace.

This is a subtle point for the Eighth Step. When you make a list of people you have harmed, it is worth checking your motives for each name. Some people belong on the list because you genuinely harmed them - you lied to them, hurt them, took from them, let them down. Others might sneak onto it for different reasons. Because you are embarrassed about what they saw. Because you want them to think well of you again. Because their opinion matters to your reputation.

Seneca’s point is that being preoccupied with how others see you - whether in scorn or admiration - is its own kind of trap. Amends made mainly to repair your reputation are not quite the same as amends made to repair a harm. The first is about you. The second is about them.

This does not mean that embarrassment and reputation are irrelevant. Drinking can damage your standing in ways that matter, and it is natural to want to repair that. But the Eighth Step is about justice - about what you owe to the people you harmed. Keeping that focus clear helps the amends be sincere.

Look at your list today. For each name, ask: did I harm this person, or am I mainly worried about what they think of me? If it is the second, consider whether they really belong on this list. Seneca would say you are freeing yourself from both scorn and admiration, and focusing on what justice actually asks.

Try this today

Look at your list. Remove anyone who is there only because of what they think of you, rather than because of a harm you did them.

Tonight

Is my list about harms done, or about my reputation?

Reflection by · quotation from Seneca in a public-domain translation

Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.