Opinion

Remember that all is opinion.
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 2.15

From Book 2 of the Meditations - one of the shortest entries in the book, just four words in Long’s translation.

Four words. Remember that all is opinion. Marcus adds a little more - that the saying of the Cynic philosopher Monimus is plain enough, and so is its use, if you take from it only as much as is true. But the heart of the entry is the reminder itself. Much of what we take for reality is our reading of it.

Marcus did not mean that nothing is real, or that facts do not matter. He meant that between events and our experience of them sits a layer of judgement, and that layer is far more flexible than it feels. “I can’t do this” is an opinion. So is “I’ve ruined everything”, “I deserve a drink”, “I’ll never be happy sober” and “everyone else can drink normally”. They feel like facts, especially at nine in the evening. They are interpretations.

For someone in recovery, this matters because so many of the thoughts that lead to drinking are opinions dressed as facts. The craving does not say, “I would quite like a drink.” It says, “You need this. You cannot get through tonight without it.” That is an opinion, and a questionable one. Plenty of people get through plenty of nights without a drink. Labelling it as opinion does not make it vanish, but it changes its status. It becomes something you can examine, rather than an order you must follow.

A simple exercise helps. Write down the thought you repeat most often about your drinking. Read it back. Write the word “opinion” next to it. Then ask whether there is a more accurate opinion available. “I can’t do this” might become “This is hard, and I have done hard things.” “I’ve ruined everything” might become “I’ve caused real damage, and I am starting to repair it.” These are still opinions, but they are truer ones, and they lead somewhere better.

Remember that all is opinion. It is one of the most freeing sentences Marcus wrote, because it means the story is never quite finished.

Try this today

Write down your most repeated thought about your drinking - “I need it to relax,” “I’ve ruined everything,” “I can’t do this.” Label it “opinion” and look at it again. Then write a more accurate opinion underneath.

Tonight

Which opinions did I treat as facts today?

Reflection by · quotation from Marcus Aurelius in a public-domain translation

Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.