Perfect security

If you take away your opinion about that which appears to give you pain, you yourself stand in perfect security.
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 8.40

From Book 8 of the Meditations. Marcus imagines an objection - “but I am not just reason” - and replies: then let the reason, at least, not trouble itself.

Marcus makes a bold claim. If you take away your opinion about whatever seems painful, you stand in perfect security. Then he imagines someone objecting: but I am not just reason. Fine, he replies. Let the reason itself, at least, not trouble itself. If some other part of you suffers, let that part have its own opinion. The reasoning mind does not have to join in.

This is a subtle distinction, and a useful one for recovery. Pain and discomfort are real. A craving is a real sensation. Physical discomfort in early sobriety is real. Emotional pain is real. Marcus does not deny any of that. What he points to is the judgement layered on top: this is unbearable, I cannot cope, this will never end, I need a drink. Those judgements are what turn discomfort into crisis.

If you can notice the judgement and set it aside, the discomfort remains, but it becomes something you can sit with. The body may ache. The craving may pull. But the reasoning part of you stays steady. It observes. It does not panic. That steadiness is the perfect security Marcus describes.

This is closely related to urge surfing and to many modern approaches to cravings. The practice is to notice the sensation without adding the story. “There is a tightness in my chest and a strong pull towards drinking.” That is the sensation. “I can’t stand this and I have to drink” is the story. One is bearable. The other often is not.

Take today’s hardest moment and separate the sensation from your judgement about it. Write both down. Notice which one is actually unbearable. Marcus would say that when you take away the judgement, you stand in perfect security - even while the body has its own opinion.

Try this today

Take today’s hardest moment - a craving, an ache, a hurt - and separate the sensation from your judgement about it. Write both down. Notice which one is actually unbearable.

Tonight

What judgement did I add today to something that hurt?

Reflection by · quotation from Marcus Aurelius in a public-domain translation

Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.