Who hinders you?

Cast away opinion - you are saved. Who then hinders you from casting it away?
Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 12.25

From Book 12 of the Meditations - a short, almost abrupt entry near the end of the book.

Marcus writes two short sentences near the end of the Meditations. Cast away opinion, and you are saved. Who, then, prevents you from casting it away? The first sentence makes a large claim. The second turns it into a challenge. If opinion is what weighs you down, and nobody can stop you letting go of it, why are you still carrying it?

The work of amends can bring up heavy opinions. “I am beyond repair.” “They will never forgive me.” “I have ruined too much.” “I do not deserve to be forgiven.” These can feel like facts, especially when you are facing the people you hurt. They make amends harder, because they say there is no point. And they make recovery harder, because they feed the shame that so often leads back to drinking.

Marcus’s challenge is to see them as opinions - judgements you are making, not truths handed down. You may have caused real harm. That is a fact. But “I am beyond repair” is a verdict, and it is not one you are qualified to give. Many people who caused great harm have repaired a great deal. Many relationships thought lost have been restored. Many people who felt they did not deserve forgiveness have been forgiven.

Who prevents you from casting the opinion away? Nobody but you. Not the people you harmed - they may forgive you, or may not, but they cannot make you believe you are beyond repair. Not your past - it happened, but it does not dictate what you believe about yourself now.

Write down one opinion about yourself that has been weighing on you through this work. Ask who is stopping you from setting it down. Marcus would say that the answer is nobody, and that you are freer than you feel.

Try this today

Write down one opinion about yourself that has been weighing on you through this work - “I’m beyond repair”, “they’ll never forgive me”. Ask who is stopping you from setting it down.

Tonight

What opinion did I carry today that I could cast away?

Reflection by · quotation from Marcus Aurelius in a public-domain translation

Quotations are from public-domain translations: Marcus Aurelius tr. George Long (1862); Epictetus tr. George Long (1877) and T. W. Higginson (1865); Seneca tr. R. M. Gummere (1917-25) and Aubrey Stewart (1889). Archaic pronouns are modernised in places. Every quotation is checked against the source text. Not medical advice.